+The need for an adequate explanation.+--But there is no subject upon
which modern Christian thought is less coherent than this. We are
constantly hearing the statement that a rational theory of the
Atonement is badly wanted, or that it is our duty to preach the fact
without a theory, or that the Atonement is such a mystery that no
theory is possible and we must just accept it on faith. This
confession of helplessness shows that there is something seriously
wrong with the conventional presentation of the doctrine. But I do not
think the Atonement is such a very great mystery after all, and it
ought to be possible to get at the heart of it without stultifying the
intellect. Anyhow, let us try.
+The usual theological method of expounding it.+--As a rule treatises
on the Atonement begin with an examination of the Scripture passages
which are supposed to have a bearing upon it. Then follows a careful
examination and criticism of the various theories of it which have
successively held the field during its history; the author concludes by
giving us his own. I do not propose to follow that method, for it does
not possess a living interest for the mind of to-day; the psychological
should take precedence of the historical. I do not feel called upon to
take the doctrine of Atonement for granted and then proceed to try to
find a place for it in Christian experience. On the contrary, I prefer
to take human nature for granted and inquire whether it needs anything
like a doctrine of Atonement. If it does not, let the doctrine go; if
it does, let us see that the doctrine is presented in a reasonable
fashion. If it cannot be presented reasonably, it is not wanted. But
I think it is wanted, and more than wanted; it is already taken for
granted by everyone who thinks seriously about life, whether it is
called by its theological name or not.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account