The New York Tombs Inside and Out!: Scenes and Reminiscences Coming Down to the Present. A Story Stranger Than Fiction, with an Historic Account of America's Most Famous Prison.Munro, John Josiah
History
The New York Tombs Inside and Out!: Scenes and Reminiscences Coming Down to the Present. A Story Stranger Than Fiction, with an Historic Account of America's Most Famous Prison.
Munro, John Josiah
Crime -- New York (State) -- New York; Halls of Justice (New York, N.Y.)
Under a paid Board of Criminal Experts, sitting daily from 10 a. m. till
5 p. m., and who are there to investigate, sift and go to the bottom of
things generally, the rich and the poor would have a better chance of
receiving justice meted out to them.
A very common opinion, which is gaining ground every day, and which is
in some respects true, is that big criminals go unpunished, while others
who are lawfully convicted of crime command such influence with the
courts or high political powers that they are able to obtain their
freedom by parole or pardon or get off with a very light sentence.
Others, after being lawfully convicted, are able to cheat the prison,
provided they have money to fight their case in the higher courts and
thus obtain a new trial which in the end means an acquittal. All this
tends to bring contempt on our courts and occasionally invites the
people to take the law into their own hands. We have too many
indictments to-day and too few convictions. Millions of dollars of the
people’s money are often wasted on cases where there is no chance of
conviction. The courts are cumbered with hundreds of cases of men and
women that should never have been indicted.
A study of the statistics of convictions in proportion to the number of
arrests and of convictions in proportion to defective indictments which
have to be set aside, and, finally, the proportion of the convicted that
finally go to prison, would prove most interesting.
When Mr. Jerome became District Attorney of New York County on the first
of January, 1902, there were 640 untried indictments awaiting action at
his hands. During his first four years in office he laid before the
Grand Jury 20,228 complaints, but they granted only 15,937 indictments.
As a result 4,291 complaints were thrown out of Court without any trial.
Then of the 15,937 cases that went to trial, 6,150 were acquitted for
lack of evidence and other technical reasons, making a grand total of
10,641 cases that were nullified by the Courts for want of legal
evidence to convict.
Of the 9,787 so-called convictions, only about a third were convicted
after a trial, the other defendants accepted pleas to lower offences,
and given that alternative simply because the District Attorney feared
that if they went to trial he would be unable to convict them.
In the Report of the Chief Clerk of the District Attorney’s Office,
which is brought down to the close of 1908, there is no mention of the
number of indictments secured by the Grand Jury last year, but it must
have been three times the number of the convictions, which was 7,877 and
then we must remember that by far the larger number of convictions were
secured by giving the prisoner a plea to a lesser offence. As a rule
when the Public Prosecutor permits a man to take a lower plea it shows
that the case against him is poor.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account