The Nile quest : $b a record of the exploration of the Nile and its basinJohnston, Harry
History
The Nile quest : $b a record of the exploration of the Nile and its basin
Johnston, Harry
Nile River
Burton returned to England in 1859, somewhat chagrined to hear of
the enthusiasm with which Speke’s discovery of the Victoria Nyanza
had been received,--an enthusiasm which to some extent had put the
revelation of Lake Tanganyika in the shade. Burton nevertheless was
awarded, in 1860, the Gold Medal of the Royal Geographical Society,
and in returning thanks for this honour, he uttered a handsome
acknowledgment of Speke’s services as surveyor on this expedition
to the great lakes. But the two men were evidently on bad terms,
and though the fault of their disaccord may have lain with Burton’s
conduct, the world knew of it first through the writings of Speke in
“Blackwood’s Magazine,” and later (in 1864) in the republication of
these Blackwood articles with additions under the title of “What Led to
the Discovery of the Source of the Nile.” In these works Speke makes
certain stinging references to Burton. So far as an impartial verdict
can be arrived at, Speke in all probability spoke the truth; but he
was perhaps unduly hard on his companion, for whom he had evidently a
great personal dislike and some degree of contempt. In some respects
Speke’s own education had been defective (at least, we are told that he
was so much of a truant as to receive but little schooling before going
to India). He may, therefore, have been unable to appreciate to the
full Burton’s undoubted talents. Yet again, in reading Speke’s books
it would occur to no one to say that he was deficient in education.
He had become an admirable geographer, a keen naturalist; and whether
his writing was or was not without grace of style, it was certainly
pithy and to the point. His great book, the “Discovery of the Source
of the Nile,” is good reading all through, and strikes one who, like
the present writer, has been over much of the same ground, as being
singularly truthful. It is as good a book as any that Burton himself
ever wrote on Africa, not excepting even the excellent “Lake Regions.”
Speke was a fine figure of a man,--tall and handsome in an English
style, with blue eyes and a brown beard. There is no doubt that he
impressed the natives favourably wherever he went as being a man and
a gentleman. Yet there was a little hardness in his disposition,
something pitiless in his criticisms of Burton. Burton’s own attacks on
Speke scarcely appeared in a public form until four years after Speke
had returned to Africa. They were angry, and somewhat clumsy, but not
so incisive as Speke’s criticisms of Burton. Burton’s chief revenge lay
in endeavouring for many years to prove that Speke had made no very
great discovery; that his Victoria Nyanza was not the greatest lake in
Africa and the main source of the Nile, but a network of swamps and
lakelets. Burton hailed with delight Sir Samuel Baker’s description
of the Albert Nyanza as being the ultimate origin of the White Nile.
To meet this view he, against his own convictions, tried to make the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account