The No Breakfast Plan and the Fasting-CureDewey, Edward Hooker
Science
The No Breakfast Plan and the Fasting-Cure
Dewey, Edward Hooker
Fasting; Nutrition
"One of those cases which a judicious editor ponders in no
little perplexity is that of a young lady who was taken out of
an insane hospital and subjected to a protracted fast, without
medical supervision, and with results that appear to have been
quite successful. On the one hand, there is the benefit that may
be derived by having the attention of the profession called to
the subject, with possibly good results; on the other hand,
there is the danger of having a lot of ignorant or impulsive
people risking their lives by starving themselves for this or
that real or fancied disease, forgetting the adage that a little
knowledge is a dangerous thing, especially in therapeutics.
"The mind of the young lady referred to became affected about a
year ago, and after what was regarded by her parents as an
unprofitable period of treatment for two and a half months in a
hospital for the insane she has been apparently cured by
fasting--some would call it starvation. The case has been
attracting attention and discussion lately in a growing circle
that has included a few physicians.
"The subject is a Miss K., aged twenty-two years. Henry Ritter,
who has charge of the Photography Department of the Drexel
Institute, and who is better acquainted with the matter than any
one else, furnished a _Ledger_ reporter with the particulars as
they are here given, the name and address of the young lady, for
obvious reasons, being omitted. Mr. Ritter was at first loath to
have any publicity given the case, but felt upon reflection that
the results were properly a subject matter for inquiry by
physicians, at least, not to speak of others who may be
interested.
"Miss K., by the advice of specialists who had treated her at
home, was put under treatment for melancholy in an institution
for the insane. Mr. Ritter, being an intimate friend of the
family, visited her, and, he says, found her retrograding. She
was receiving three meals a day, with two luncheons between
them. Having built up his own digestive powers by following the
tenets laid down by Dr. Dewey, a Crawford county physician, he
had become a student and advocate of the latter's theory,
briefly stated, that no food should be given to a patient except
in response to a natural call or appetite for it. Believing that
no improvement could result from the course Miss K. was
receiving in the hospital, he prevailed upon her parents to
permit him to have her placed in the home of a friend, and
suggested the fasting process. This was the more readily done as
the physicians in whose care she had been advised her parents to
leave their daughter as much as possible among strangers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account