The North Americans of Antiquity: Their origin, migrations, and type of civilization consideredShort, John T. (John Thomas)
History
The North Americans of Antiquity: Their origin, migrations, and type of civilization considered
Short, John T. (John Thomas)
Indians -- Origin; Indians of Mexico -- Antiquities; Indians of North America -- Antiquities
It is with the utmost deference to the genius, and with full
recognition of the valuable researches of Dr. Morton, that we disagree
with his conclusions and pronounce his theory without foundation in
fact. There is no evidence furnished by the measurement of crania
that an American race, as unique in itself and distinct from the rest
of mankind, ever existed.[231] One of the most interesting studies
connected with these tables, as well as other measurements made
more recently, is the question of relationship between the various
semi-civilized peoples of the ancient period. First and most naturally
the type of the mound crania attracts attention, and calls for
comparisons with the Indian type and with that of the remarkable people
of the more southern civilization.
The “Scioto Mound” skull figured by Dr. Davis in Plates xlvii and
xlviii of _The Ancient Monuments of the Mississippi Valley_, was
pronounced by Dr. Morton in Dr. Meigs’ catalogue of the human crania in
the collection of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, as
“perhaps the most admirably formed head of the American race hitherto
discovered.”
The most important measurements are as follows:
Longitudinal diameter 6.5 inches.
Parietal „ 6.0 „
Vertical „ 6.2 „
Inter-mastoid arch 16.0 „
Horizontal circumference 19.8 „
————
Cephalic index 92.3 „
The chief features as pointed out by the above-named author, are: the
elevated vertex, flattened occiput, great inter-parietal diameter,
ponderous bony structure, salient nose, large jaws and broad face.
These he pronounces to be characteristics of the American cranium. Dr.
Wilson has shown that Dr. Morton has contradicted his own previous
definition of what that type is as well as the description given by
Humboldt.[232] The propriety of selecting any single cranium as typical
of the Mound-builders would be as questionable in this connection as
it was for Dr. Morton and the authors of the _Types of Mankind_ to
designate the Scioto Mound skull as a type of the American cranium.
Until within a few years but few genuine mound skulls were accessible,
and considerable suspicion was reasonably attached to the genuineness
of several, including three or four of the so-called mound skulls in
the _Crania Americana_. Recent explorations have brought to light a
large number, of unquestioned genuineness. The Peabody Museum alone
possesses 300, and of these 200 were exhumed by Prof. F. W. Putnam.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account