Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
The modern schoolmaster does not aim at learning from his pupils, he
hardly can, but the old masters did. See how Giovanni Bellini learned
from Titian and Giorgione who both came to him in the same year, as boys,
when Bellini was 63 years old. What a day for painting was that! All
Bellini’s best work was done thenceforward. I know nothing in the
history of art so touching as this. [1883.]
P.S. I have changed my mind about Titian. I don’t like him. [1897.]
The Academic System and Repentance
The academic system goes almost on the principle of offering places for
repentance, and letting people fall soft, by assuming that they should be
taught how to do things before they do them, and not by the doing of
them. Good economy requires that there should be little place for
repentance, and that when people fall they should fall hard enough to
remember it.
The Jubilee Sixpence
We have spent hundreds of thousands, or more probably of millions, on
national art collections, schools of art, preliminary training and
academicism, without wanting anything in particular, but when the nation
did at last try all it knew to design a sixpence, it failed. {136} The
other coins are all very well in their way, and so are the stamps—the
letters get carried, and the money passes; but both stamps and coins
would have been just as good, and very likely better, if there had not
been an art-school in the country. [1888.]
Studying from Nature
When is a man studying from nature, and when is he only flattering
himself that he is doing so because he is painting with a model or
lay-figure before him? A man may be working his eight or nine hours a
day from the model and yet not be studying from nature. He is painting
but not studying. He is like the man in the Bible who looks at himself
in a glass and goeth away forgetting what manner of man he was. He will
know no more about nature at the end of twenty years than a priest who
has been reading his breviary day after day without committing it to
memory will know of its contents. Unless he gets what he has seen well
into his memory, so as to have it at his fingers’ ends as familiarly as
the characters with which he writes a letter, he can be no more held to
be familiar with, and to have command over, nature than a man who only
copies his signature from a copy kept in his pocket, as I have known
French Canadians do, can be said to be able to write. It is painting
without nature that will give a man this, and not painting directly from
her. He must do both the one and the other, and the one as much as the
other.
The Model and the Lay-Figure
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account