Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
Arguments are not so good as assertion. Arguments are like fire-arms
which a man may keep at home but should not carry about with him.
Indirect assertion, leaving the hearer to point the inference, is, as a
rule, to be preferred. The one great argument with most people is that
another should think this or that. The reasons of the belief are details
and, in nine cases out of ten, best omitted as confusing and weakening
the general impression.
Many, if not most, good ideas die young—mainly from neglect on the part
of the parents, but sometimes from over-fondness. Once well started, an
opinion had better be left to shift for itself.
Insist as far as possible on the insignificance of the points of
difference as compared with the resemblances to opinions generally
accepted.
Gladstone as a Financier
I said to my tobacconist that Gladstone was not a financier because he
bought a lot of china at high prices and it fetched very little when it
was sold at Christie’s.
“Did he give high prices?” said the tobacconist.
“Enormous prices,” said I emphatically.
Now, to tell the truth, I did not know whether Mr. Gladstone had ever
bought the china at all, much less what he gave for it, if he did; he may
have had it all left him for aught I knew. But I was going to appeal to
my tobacconist by arguments that he could understand, and I could see he
was much impressed.
Argument
Argument is generally waste of time and trouble. It is better to present
one’s opinion and leave it to stick or no as it may happen. If sound, it
will probably in the end stick, and the sticking is the main thing.
Humour
What a frightful thing it would be if true humour were more common or,
rather, more easy to see, for it is more common than those are who can
see it. It would block the way of everything. Perhaps this is what
people rather feel. It would be like Music in the _Ode for St. Cecilia’s
Day_, it would “untune the sky.”
I do not know quite what is meant by untuning the sky and, if I did, I
cannot think that there is anything to be particularly gained by having
the sky untuned; still, if it has got to be untuned at all, I am sure
music is the only thing that can untune it. Rapson, however, whom I used
to see in the coin room at the British Museum, told me it should be
“entune the sky” and it sounds as though he were right.
Myself and “Unconscious Humour”
The phrase “unconscious humour” is the one contribution I have made to
the current literature of the day. I am continually seeing unconscious
humour (without quotation marks) alluded to in _Times_ articles and other
like places, but I never remember to have come across it as a synonym for
dullness till I wrote _Life and Habit_.
My Humour
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account