Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
When I say the artist tends towards such a world, I mean not that he
tends consciously and reasoningly but that his instinct to take this
direction will be too strong to let him take any other. He is incapable
of reasoning on the subject; if he could reason he would be lost _qua_
artist; for, by every test that reason can apply, those who sell
themselves for a price are in the right. The artist is guided by a faith
that for him transcends all reason. Granted that this faith has been in
great measure founded on reason, that it has grown up along with reason,
that if it lose touch with reason it is no longer faith but madness;
granted, again, that reason is in great measure founded on faith, that it
has grown up along with faith, that if it lose touch with faith it is no
longer reason but mechanism; granted, therefore, that faith grows with
reason as will with power, as demand with supply, as mind with body, each
stimulating and augmenting the other until an invisible, minute nucleus
attains colossal growth—nevertheless the difference between the man of
the world and the man who lives by faith is that the first is drawn
towards the one and the second towards the other of two principles which,
so far as we can see, are co-extensive and co-equal in importance.
Money
It is curious that money, which is the most valuable thing in life,
_exceptis excipiendis_, should be the most fatal corrupter of music,
literature, painting and all the arts. As soon as any art is pursued
with a view to money, then farewell, in ninety-nine cases out of a
hundred, all hope of genuine good work. If a man has money at his back,
he may touch these things and do something which will live a long while,
and he may be very happy in doing it; if he has no money, he may do good
work, but the chances are he will be killed in doing it and for having
done it; or he may make himself happy by doing bad work and getting money
out of it, and there is no great harm in this, provided he knows his work
is done in this spirit and rates it for its commercial value only.
Still, as a rule, a man should not touch any of the arts as a creator
unless be has a _discreta posizionina_ behind him.
Modern Simony
It is not the dealing in livings but the thinking they can buy the Holy
Ghost for money which vulgar rich people indulge in when they dabble in
literature, music and painting.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account