Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
My reviewers felt no sense of need to understand me—if they had they
would have developed the mental organism which would have enabled them to
do so. When the time comes that they want to do so they will throw out a
little mental pseudopodium without much difficulty. They threw it out
when they wanted to misunderstand me—with a good deal of the pseudo in
it, too.
The Authoress of the Odyssey
The amount of pains which my reviewers have taken to understand this book
is not so great as to encourage the belief that they would understand the
_Odyssey_, however much they studied it. Again, the people who could
read the _Odyssey_ without coming to much the same conclusions as mine
are not likely to admit that they ought to have done so.
If a man tells me that a house in which I have long lived is
inconvenient, not to say unwholesome, and that I have been very stupid in
not finding this out for myself, I should be apt in the first instance to
tell him that he knew nothing about it, and that I was quite comfortable;
by and by, I should begin to be aware that I was not so comfortable as I
thought I was, and in the end I should probably make the suggested
alterations in my house if, on reflection, I found them sensibly
conceived. But I should kick hard at first.
Homer and his Commentators
Homeric commentators have been blind so long that nothing will do for
them but Homer must be blind too. They have transferred their own
blindness to the poet.
The Iliad
In the _Iliad_, civilisation bursts upon us as a strong stream out of a
rock. We know that the water has gathered from many a distant vein
underground, but we do not see these. Or it is like the drawing up the
curtain on the opening of a play—the scene is then first revealed.
Glacial Periods of Folly
The moraines left by secular glacial periods of folly stretch out over
many a plain of our civilisation. So in the _Odyssey_, especially in the
second twelve books, whenever any one eats meat it is called
“sacrificing” it, as though we were descended from a race that did not
eat meat. Then it was said that meat might be eaten if one did not eat
the life. What was the life? Clearly the blood, for when you stick a
pig it lives till the blood is gone. You must sacrifice the blood,
therefore, to the gods, but so long as you abstain from things strangled
and from blood, and so long as you call it sacrificing, you may eat as
much meat as you please.
What a mountain of lies—what a huge geological formation of falsehood,
with displacement of all kinds, and strata twisted every conceivable way,
must have accreted before the _Odyssey_ was possible!
Translations from Verse into Prose
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account