Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
When Christianity convulsed the world and displaced the older mythology,
she did but introduce new subjects of her own, to which her artists kept
as closely as their pagan ancestors had kept to their heathen gods and
goddesses. We now make believe to have freed ourselves from these
trammels, but the departure is more apparent than real. Our works of art
fall into a few well-marked groups and the pictures of each group, though
differing in detail, present the same general characters. We have,
however, broken much new ground, whereas until the last three or four
hundred years it almost seems either as if artists had thought subject a
detail beneath their notice, or publics had insisted on being told only
what they knew already.
The principle of living only to see and to hear some new thing, and the
other principle of avoiding everything with which we are not perfectly
familiar are equally old, equally universal, equally useful. They are
the principles of conservation and accumulation on the one hand, and of
adventure, speculation and progress on the other, each equally
indispensable. The money has been, and will probably always be more
persistently in the hands of the first of these two groups. But, after
all, is not money an art? Nay, is it not the most difficult on earth and
the parent of all? And if life is short and art long, is not money still
longer? And are not works of art, for the most part, more or less works
of money also? In so far as a work of art is a work of money, it must
not complain of being bound by the laws of money; in so far as it is a
work of art, it has nothing to do with money and, again, cannot complain.
It is a great help to the spectator to know the subject of a picture and
not to be bothered with having to find out all about the story. Subjects
should be such as either tell their own story instantly on the face of
them, or things with which all spectators may be supposed familiar. It
must not be forgotten that a work exposed to public view is addressed to
a great many people and should accordingly consider many people rather
than one. I saw an English family not long since looking at a fine
collection of the coins of all nations. They hardly pretended even to
take a languid interest in the French, German, Dutch and Italian coins,
but brightened up at once on being shown a shilling, a florin and a
half-crown. So children do not want new stories; they look for old ones.
“Mamma dear, will you please tell us the story of ‘The Three Bears’?”
“No, my love, not to-day, I have told it you very often lately and I am
busy.”
“Very well, Mamma dear, then we will tell you the story of ‘The Three
Bears.’”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account