Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
One man who entered for the Chancellor’s medal declined to answer any of
the questions set. He said he saw they were intended more to show off
the ingenuity of the examiner than either to assist or test the judgment
of the examined. He observed, moreover, that the view taken of his
answers would in great measure depend upon what the examiner had had for
dinner and, since it was not in his power to control this, he was not
going to waste time where the result was, at best, so much a matter of
chance. Briefly, his view of life was that the longer you lived and the
less you thought or talked about it the better. He should go pretty
straight in the main himself because it saved trouble on the whole, and
he should be guided mainly by a sense of humour in deciding when to
deviate from the path of technical honesty, and he would take care that
his errors, if any, should be rather on the side of excess than of
asceticism
This man won the Chancellor’s medal.
They have a review class in which the pupils are taught not to mind what
is written in newspapers. As a natural result they grow up more keenly
sensitive than ever.
Round the margin of the newspapers sentences are printed cautioning the
readers against believing the criticisms they see, inasmuch as personal
motives will underlie the greater number.
They defend the universities and academic bodies on the ground that, but
for them, good work would be so universal that the world would become
clogged with masterpieces to an extent that would reduce it to an
absurdity. Good sense would rule over all, and merely smart or clever
people would be unable to earn a living.
They assume that truth is best got at by the falling out of thieves.
“Well then, there must be thieves, or how can they fall out? Our
business is to produce the raw material from which truth may be
elicited.”
“And you succeed, sir,” I replied, “in a way that is beyond all praise,
and it seems as though there would be no limit to the supply of truth
that ought to be available. But, considering the number of your thieves,
they show less alacrity in flying at each other’s throats than might have
been expected.”
They live their lives backwards, beginning, as old men and women, with
little more knowledge of the past than we have of the future, and
foreseeing the future about as clearly as we see the past, winding up by
entering into the womb as though being buried. But delicacy forbids me
to pursue this subject further: the upshot is that it comes to much the
same thing, provided one is used to it.
Paying debts is a luxury which we cannot all of us afford.
“It is not every one, my dear, who can reach such a counsel of perfection
as murder.”
There was no more space for the chronicles and, what was worse, there was
no more space in which anything could happen at all, the whole land had
become one vast cancerous growth of chronicles, chronicles, chronicles,
nothing but chronicles.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account