Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
When we consider how little we have to do with our parentage, country and
education, or even with our genus and species, how vitally these things
affect us both in life and death, and how, practically, the cunning in
connection with them is so spent as to be no cunning at all, it is plain
that the drifts, currents, and storms of what is virtually luck will be
often more than the little helm of cunning can control. And so with
death. Nothing can affect us less, but at the same time nothing can
affect us more; and how little can cunning do against it? At the best it
can only defer it. Cunning is nine-tenths luck, and luck is nine-tenths
cunning; but the fact that nine-tenths of cunning is luck leaves still a
tenth part unaccounted for.
Choice
Our choice is apparently most free, and we are least obviously driven to
determine our course, in those cases where the future is most obscure,
that is, when the balance of advantage appears most doubtful.
Where we have an opinion that assures us promptly which way the balance
of advantage will incline—whether it be an instinctive, hereditarily
acquired opinion or one rapidly and decisively formed as the result of
post-natal experience—then our action is determined at once by that
opinion, and freedom of choice practically vanishes.
Ego and Non-Ego
You can have all ego, or all non-ego, but in theory you cannot have half
one and half the other—yet in practice this is exactly what you must
have, for everything is both itself and not itself at one and the same
time.
A living thing is itself in so far as it has wants and gratifies them.
It is not itself in so far as it uses itself as a tool for the gratifying
of its wants. Thus an amœba is aware of a piece of meat which it wants
to eat. It has nothing except its own body to fling at the meat and
catch it with. If it had a little hand-net, or even such an organ as our
own hand, it would use it, but it has only got itself; so it takes itself
by the scruff of its own neck, as it were, and flings itself at the piece
of meat, as though it were not itself but something which it is using in
order to gratify itself. So we make our own bodies into carriages every
time we walk. Our body is our tool-box—and our bodily organs are the
simplest tools we can catch hold of.
When the amœba has got the piece of meat and has done digesting it, it
leaves off being not itself and becomes itself again. A thing is only
itself when it is doing nothing; as long as it is doing something it is
its own tool and not itself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account