Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
No man should try even to allude to the greater part of what he sees in
his subject, and there is hardly a limit to what he may omit. What is
required is that he shall say what he elects to say discreetly; that he
shall be quick to see the gist of a matter, and give it pithily without
either prolixity or stint of words.
Relative Importances
It is the painter’s business to help memory and imagination, not to
supersede them. He cannot put the whole before the spectator, nothing
can do this short of the thing itself; he should, therefore, not try to
realise, and the less he looks as if he were trying to do so the more
signs of judgment he will show. His business is to supply those details
which will most readily bring the whole before the mind along with them.
He must not give too few, but it is still more imperative on him not to
give too many.
Seeing, thought and expression are rendered possible only by the fact
that our minds are always ready to compromise and to take the part for
the whole. We associate a number of ideas with any given object, and if
a few of the most characteristic of these are put before us we take the
rest as read, jump to a conclusion and realise the whole. If we did not
conduct our thought on this principle—simplifying by suppression of
detail and breadth of treatment—it would take us a twelvemonth to say
that it was a fine morning and another for the hearer to apprehend our
statement. Any other principle reduces thought to an absurdity.
All painting depends upon simplification. All simplification depends
upon a perception of relative importances. All perception of relative
importances depends upon a just appreciation of which letters in
association’s bond association will most readily dispense with. This
depends upon the sympathy of the painter both with his subject and with
him who is to look at the picture. And this depends upon a man’s common
sense.
He therefore tells best in painting, as in literature, who has best
estimated the relative values or importances of the more special features
characterising his subject: that is to say, who appreciates most
accurately how much and how fast each one of them will carry, and is at
most pains to give those only that will say most in the fewest words or
touches. It is here that the most difficult, the most important, and the
most generally neglected part of an artist’s business will be found to
lie.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account