Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
It takes as great a composer as Handel—or rather it would take as great a
composer if he could be found—to be able to be as easily and triumphantly
commonplace as Handel often is, just as it takes—or rather would take—as
great a composer as Handel to write another _Hallelujah_ chorus. It is
only the man who can do the latter who can do the former as Handel has
done it. Handel is so great and so simple that no one but a professional
musician is unable to understand him.
Handel and Dr. Morell
After all, Dr. Morell suited Handel exactly well—far better than Tennyson
would have done. I don’t believe even Handel could have set Tennyson to
music comfortably. What a mercy it is that he did not live in Handel’s
time! Even though Handel had set him ever so well he would have spoiled
the music, and this Dr. Morell does not in the least do.
Wordsworth
And I have been as far as Hull to see
What clothes he left or other property.
I am told that these lines occur in a poem by Wordsworth. (Think of the
expense!) How thankful we ought to be that Wordsworth was only a poet
and not a musician. Fancy a symphony by Wordsworth! Fancy having to sit
it out! And fancy what it would have been if he had written fugues!
Sleeping Beauties
There are plenty of them. Take Handel; look at such an air as “Loathsome
urns, disclose your treasure” or “Come, O Time, and thy broad wings
displaying,” both in _The Triumph of Time and Truth_, or at “Convey me to
some peaceful shore,” in _Alexander Balus_, especially when he comes to
“Forgetting and forgot the will of fate.” Who know these? And yet, can
human genius do more?
“And the Glory of the Lord”
It would be hard to find a more satisfactory chorus even in the
_Messiah_, but I do not think the music was originally intended for these
words:
[Picture: Music score: And the glory, the glory of the Lord]
If Handel had approached these words without having in his head a subject
the spirit of which would do, and which he thought the words with a
little management might be made to fit, he would not, I think, have
repeated “the glory” at all, or at any rate not here. If these words had
been measured, as it were, for a new suit instead of being, as I suppose,
furnished with a good second-hand one, the word “the” would not have been
tacked on to the “glory” which precedes it and made to belong to it
rather than to the “glory” which follows. It does not matter one straw,
and if Handel had asked me whether I minded his forcing the words a
little, I should have said, “Certainly not, nor more than a little, if
you like.” Nevertheless I think as a matter of fact that there is a
little forcing. I remember that as a boy this always struck me as a
strange arrangement of the words, but it was not until I came to write a
chorus myself that I saw how it came about. I do not suspect any forcing
when it comes to “And all flesh shall see it together.”
Handel and the Speaking Voice
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account