The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
acquainted, as Rambam tells us, with medicine, astronomy, and all the
existing systems of idolatry, and moreover skilled in magic. And,
besides all this, all these persons were fine handsome fellows, “Men of
stature, men of good appearance.” Is this credible—can all Israel, or
all the world, furnish one such person at present, handsome or ugly,
tall or short? or can there be found amongst that intelligent people the
Jews, one man, woman, or child, so silly as to believe so manifest a
falsehood? We can tell them that their great rabbi, Rambam, did not
believe it, and therefore in his Compendium took the liberty of altering
this Talmudic statement. Instead of seventy languages, he says simply—
ושידעו ברוב הלשונות ׃
“And that they should be acquainted with most languages.” It was too
much for him. Being a learned man himself, he knew the impossibility of
such universal knowledge; and he therefore softened down the Talmudic
hyperbole to the limits of what he considered possibility. This is not
merely our conclusion from Rambam’s alteration, the commentator has
expressly said the same:—
וכתב רבינו יודעין ברוב הלשונות משום דדבר זר להמצא מי שידע בכל ע׳ לשון ׃
“Our rabbi has written, ‘Acquainted with most languages,’ because it is
a rarity to find a person acquainted with all the seventy languages.”
(Hilchoth Sanhedrin, c. 2.) Rambam himself, then, is here a witness
against the fabulous exaggerations of the Talmud.
But perhaps some one will say, that seventy is only a round number to
signify many, that we must not, therefore, be too strict in its
exposition. This subterfuge, however, will not serve here. The authors
of the Talmud said seventy, because they believed that, by giving this
number, they included all the languages in the world. They believed that
there were seventy nations, and therefore they said seventy languages.
This article of Jewish faith is found everywhere in the Talmud, and in
the commentaries, as for instance—
אמר ר׳ יוחנן מאי דכתיב יתן אומר המבשרות צבא רב כל דבור ודבור שיצא מפי
הגבורה נחלק לשבעים לשונות ׃
“R. Johannan says, What is the meaning of that Scripture, ‘The Lord gave
the Word: great was the company of those that published it?’ It teaches,
that as each commandment proceeded from the mouth of God, it was divided
into seventy languages.” (Shabbath, fol. 88, col. 2.) The foundation of
this opinion is an arbitrary interpretation or a verse in the song of
Moses. “When the Most High divided to the nations their inheritance,
when he separated the sons of Adam, he set the bounds of the people
according to the number of the children of Israel.” (Deut. xxxii. 8.)
Upon which Rashi thus comments:—
בשביל מספר בני ישראל שעתידין לצאת מבני שם ילמספר שבעים נפש של בני ישראל
שירדו למצרים הציב גבולות עמים שבעים לשון ׃
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account