The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
We said, in our last number, that “the pious of the nations of the
world” are, according to the oral law, those who have received the seven
commandments of the sons of Noah. We said that of the laws laid down for
their own conduct, some, as for instance that respecting divorces, are
such as would introduce confusion and misery into Gentile society—and
that others, referring to the administration of justice by Rabbinical
tribunals, are extremely unjust. But the advocates of the oral law
think, nevertheless, that it is very tolerant, more tolerant than the
New Testament, because it says that “the pious of the nations of the
world have a share in the world to come.” Now we cannot help feeling a
curiosity to know how great or how small that share will be. And this
our curiosity is excited by the following information, which the oral
law commands to be communicated to a Gentile who wishes to turn Jew:—
וכשם שמודיעין אותו עונשן של מצוות כך מודיעין אותו שכרן של מצוות ,
ומודיעין אותו שבעשית מצוות אלו יזכה לחיי העולם הבא , ושאין שום צדיק גמור
אלא בעל החכמה שעושה ויודען ׃ ואומרים לו הוי יודע שהעולם הבא אינו צפון
אלא לצדיקים והם ישראל , וזה שתראה ישראל בצער בעולם הזה טובה היא צפונה
להם שאין יכולין לקבל רוב טובה בעולם הזה כאומות , שמא ירום לבם ויתעו
ויפסידו שכר העולם הבא כענין שנאמר וישמן ישורון ויבעט ׃ ואין הקדוש ברוך
הוא מביא עליהן רוב פורענות כדי שלא יאבדו אלא כל האומות כלין והן עומדין
וכו׳ ׃
“As they are to make known to him the punishments attached to the
commandments, so they are also to inform him of the rewards for keeping
them. They should inform him, that, by the doing of these commandments,
he will be worthy of everlasting life; and that there is no perfectly
righteous man, except that possessor of wisdom who does and knows them.
And they are to say to him, Be assured that _the world to come is laid
up for none but the righteous, and they are Israel_; and as to this that
thou seest Israel in trouble in this world, their good things are laid
up for them, _for they cannot receive an abundance of good things in
this world, like the nations_. Their heart might, perchance, be lifted
up, and they might go astray, and lose the reward of the world to come,
as it is said, ‘Jeshurun waxed fat and kicked.’ The Holy One, blessed be
he, brings upon them the abundance of afflictions for no other reason
than this, that they may not be lost. _All the nations shall be utterly
destroyed_, but they shall abide.” (Hilchoth Issure Biah., c. xiv. 3-5.)
To us this sounds very much like a flat contradiction to the above
declaration, that “the pious of the nations of the world have a share in
the world to come.” Here, on the contrary, it is stated that the
blessings of that state are reserved “for none but the righteous, and
they are Israel;” and again, “All the nations snail be utterly
destroyed.” And it is even implied that the nations get their good
things in this world, and do not suffer affliction, as they are not to
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account