The origin and development of the moral ideasWestermarck, Edward
Philosophy
The origin and development of the moral ideas
Westermarck, Edward
Ethics; Ethics -- History; Prehistoric peoples
Whilst resentment on behalf of injuries inflicted upon persons who are
unable to avenge themselves has thus, to some extent, contributed
towards the establishment of a central judicial and executive
authority, the sympathy naturally felt for the object of an improper
and immoderate revenge undoubtedly tended to bring about a similar
result. The same feeling which checked indiscriminate revenge by
establishing the rule of strict equivalence, restricted it once more,
and in a more effective way, by referring the case to a judge who was
less partial, and more discriminate, than the sufferer himself or his
friends. Speaking of the feuds of the Teutons, Kemble remarks,
"Setting aside the loss to the whole community which may arise from
private feud, the moral sense of men may be shocked by its results: an
individual's own estimate of the satisfaction necessary to atone for
the injury done to him, may lead to the commission of a wrong on his
part, greater than any he hath suffered; nor can the strict rule of
'an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth,' be applied where the
exaction of the penalty depends upon the measure of force between
appellant and defender."[90] In the Island of Bali the judge steps in
between the prosecutor and the person whom he pursues, "so as to
restrain the indiscriminate animosity of the one, and to determine the
criminality of the other."[91] Crawfurd, in his account of native
customs in the Malay Archipelago, says that "the law even expressly
interdicts all interference when there appears a character of fairness
in the quarrel."[92] A Karen, we are told, always thinks himself right
in taking the law into his own hands, this being the custom of the
country, and "he is never interfered with, unless he is guilty of some
{182} act contrary to Karen ideas of propriety, when the elders and
the villagers interfere and exercise a check upon him."[93] Among the
Basutos the authority of the chief is stated to be "sufficiently
respected to protect criminated persons, until their cases have been
lawfully examined."[94] Among the Californian Gallinomero the avenger
of blood has his option between money and the murderer's life; "but he
does not seem to be allowed to wreak on him a personal and
irresponsible vengeance," the chief taking the criminal and executing
the punishment.[95]
[Footnote 90: Kemble, _Saxons in England_, i. 268 _sq._]
[Footnote 91: Raffles, _History of Java_, ii. p. ccxxxvii.]
[Footnote 92: Crawfurd, _History of the Indian Archipelago_, iii. 120.]
[Footnote 93: Mason, in _Jour. Asiatic Soc. Bengal_, xxxvii. pt. li.
145. _Cf._ MacMahon, _Far Cathay and Farther India_, p. 188.]
[Footnote 94: Casalis, _op. cit._ p. 226.]
[Footnote 95: Powers, _Tribes of California_, p. 177.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account