The origin and development of the moral ideasWestermarck, Edward
Philosophy
The origin and development of the moral ideas
Westermarck, Edward
Ethics; Ethics -- History; Prehistoric peoples
[Footnote 99: Austrian (Finger, _op. cit._ i. 110), Dutch (van Hamel,
in _Législation pénale comparée_, edited by von Liszt, p. 444),
Portuguese (Tavares de Medeiros, _ibid._ p. 199), Russian (Foinitzki,
_ibid._ p. 529) law.]
[Footnote 100: German _Strafgesetzbuch_, art. 55.]
[Footnote 101: Swedish (Uppström, in _Législation pénale comparée_, p.
483), Finnish (Forsman, _ibid._ p. 565) law.]
[Footnote 102: French, Belgian, Ottoman law (Rivière, _ibid._ p. 7).]
[Footnote 103: _Code Pénal_, art. 66 _sqq._]
[Footnote 104: Stephen, _op. cit._ ii. 98. Kenny, _Outlines of
Criminal Law_, p. 50.]
[Footnote 105: _Strafgesetzbuch_, art. 56.]
[Footnote 106: Dutch law (van Hamel, _loc. cit._ p. 444).]
[Footnote 107: Spanish (_Código Penal reformado_, art. 9, § 2),
Swedish (Uppström, _loc. cit._ p. 484), Finnish (Forsman, _loc. cit._
p. 566) law.]
[Footnote 108: Austrian law (Finger, _op. cit._ i. 112).]
[Footnote 109: Italian (_Codice Penale_, art. 56), Russian (Foinitzki,
_loc. cit._ p. 529), Portuguese (Tavares de Medeiros, _loc. cit._ p.
199), Brazilian (_Codigo Penal dos Estados Unidos do Brazil_, art. 42,
§ 11) law. According to the _Ottoman Penal Code_, art. 40, "a guilty
person who has not arrived at the age of puberty may not be punished
with the punishment enacted against the offence of which he has been
found guilty."]
Roman law, as it seems, made out a _præsumptio juris_ of general
incapacity to commit a crime under puberty, rebuttable by evidence of
capacity, at any rate in the age called "next to puberty," the limits
of which are not clearly settled.[110] In the Irish Book of Aicill it
is said that "the man who incites a fool is he who pays for his
crime"; and to this the Commentary adds that a man is a fool till the
end of seven years, and a fool of half sense till the end of
fourteen[111]--a provision similar to that of Canon Law.[112]
According to Muhammedan law, the rule of talion is applicable only to
persons of age.[113] In China criminal responsibility is affected not
only by youth, but by old age as well. "Offenders whose age is not
more than seven nor less than ninety years, shall not suffer
punishment in any case, except in that of treason or rebellion." "Any
offender whose age is not more than ten nor less than eighty years, .
. . shall, when the crime is capital, but not {267} amounting to
treason, be recommended to the particular consideration and decision
of His Imperial Majesty." And "any offender whose age is not more than
fifteen, nor less than seventy years . . . shall be allowed to redeem
himself from any punishment less than capital, by the payment of the
established fine, except in the case of persons condemned to
banishment as accessories to the crimes of treason, rebellion, murder
of three or more persons in one family, or homicide by magic or
poisoning, upon all of which offenders the laws shall be strictly
executed."[114]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account