The first attempt to deal with this question was made by Goethe and Oken.
They considered that the cranial skeleton was composed of a series of
vertebræ, but as early as 1842 Vogt pointed out that only the occipital
segments could be reduced to vertebræ. In 1869, Huxley showed that vertebræ
were insufficient to explain the cranial segmentation, and that the nerves
must be specially considered. The olfactory and optic nerves he regarded as
parts of the brain, not true segmental nerves; the rest of the cranial
nerves {259}were segmental, with special reference to branchial arches and
clefts, the facial, glossopharyngeal, and separate vagus branches supplying
the walls of the various branchial pouches. In a similar manner, the supra-
and infra-maxillary branches of the trigeminal were arranged on each side
of the mouth, and the inner and outer twigs of the first (ophthalmic)
branch of the trigeminal on each side of the orbito-nasal cleft, the
trabecular and the supra-maxillary arches being those on each side of this
cleft. Thus Huxley considered that there was evidence of a series of pairs
of ventral arches belonging to the skull, viz. the trabecular and maxillary
in front of the mouth, the mandibular, hyoid, and branchial arches behind,
and that the Vth, VIIth, IXth, and Xth nerves were segmental in relation to
these arches and clefts. Gegenbaur, in 1871 and 1872, considered that the
branchial arches represented the lower arches of cranial vertebræ, and
therefore corresponded to lower arches in the spinal region, _i.e._ the
skull was composed of as many vertebræ as there are branchial arches. These
vertebræ were confined to the notochordal part of the skull, the prechordal
part having arisen secondarily from the vertebral part, while the number of
vertebræ are at least nine, possibly more. The nerves which could be
homologized with spinal nerves were, he thought, divisible into two great
groups--(1) the trigeminal group, which included the eye-muscle nerves, the
facial, and its dorsal branch, the auditory; (2) the vagus group, which
included the glossopharyngeal and vagus.
Such was the outcome of the purely comparative anatomical work of Huxley
and Gegenbaur--work that has profoundly influenced all the views of
segmentation up to the present day.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account