The pedigree of fascism : $b A popular essay on the Western philosophy of politicsLion, Aline
Philosophy
The pedigree of fascism : $b A popular essay on the Western philosophy of politics
Lion, Aline
Italy -- Politics and government -- 1914-1945; Partito nazionale fascista (Italy); Political science; State, The
A distinction is, however, made by Croce between the knowledge required
for a practical act, such as the disposing of a regiment of infantry
for a review, and that of the philosopher or the artist. The one
is an intuition, the other is a conception, and to make the ground
of a volition you want both, for the combination is _historical_
knowledge. There, obviously enough, Croce reveals himself a true son of
Machiavelli, Vico, and de Sanctis. The Florentine secretary had been
hinting as much when he insisted on the necessity of our knowing the
_actual truth about things_ (since _human things are always moving_),
in order to govern _in harmony with the times_.
This _historical_ knowledge is not an idea that will surprise after all
that has been said about the constant tendency of Italy’s best thinkers
to test the practicability of any concept on the concrete ground of
history. To them, the natural realm of action being history, it was
manifest that any knowledge or theory is liable to be acted upon only
in so far as it is historical; and such knowledge becomes, under the
name of condition of fact, the ground of Croce’s conception of the
necessity and liberty of man’s will.
To the generally accepted ideas of means and end Croce was to bring a
most radical change. First he proceeds to prove that what is known as
the end, the purpose, or the aim is not to be distinguished from the
will. When I wash my hands my purpose is obviously that I should have
them clean; but then it is equally obvious that this means that I want
them to be clean. Turning to the means, the washing of my hands in
order to have them clean, supposes a condition of fact which means the
availableness of soap and water, for I could not will to wash my hands
if I had neither soap nor water. These material means are known by me
to be available when I make up my mind to wash my hands in order to get
them clean. So that purpose and means are all included in my act of
will, which is nothing more nor less than the actual act of washing my
hands. If the situation of fact did not include soap and water I could
at best _wish_ to wash them, never _will_ to do so.
What is consequently to be rejected once for all is the idea of a
definite plan that would not allow the taking into consideration of
the continual variation of the means. Thus the men of the Risorgimento
had to vary their purpose and to reconsider the means to attain it
after and before each campaign, having to take as their actual will
only that the realisation of which was in harmony with the then actual
situation of fact. So that we can say that their real will, the will
which created modern Italy, was exclusively that general will which was
individualised in their many splendid deeds of heroism or renunciations
of their former plans or ideals; these had been formed without the
historical knowledge which alone could make them realise what was the
situation of fact.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account