It must be admitted that it is difficult to describe more precisely
than we have done above what is meant by these terms. It is with very
much the same embarrassment that is experienced by the physicist
when he has to apply the concepts of mass and inertia, in their
eighteenth-century meaning, to his description of an universe in terms
of electro-magnetic theory, that we seek to describe the modern concept
of entelechy. Yet the physicist has had to make this step forward,
and the same adventure awaits the biologist if the speculative side
of his science is to make further progress, and if he is disinclined
to make his science an appendage of physics and chemistry. Entelechy
does not correspond to the eighteenth-century notion of a “vital
force,” or to the “soul” of Descartes, as the writer of a book on
evolutionary biology seems to suggest. It is a concept which is forced
upon us mainly because of the failure of mechanistic hypotheses of the
organism. If our physical analysis of the behaviour of the developing
embryo, or the evolving race or stock, or the activities of the
organism in the midst of an ever-changing environment, or even the
reactions of the functioning gland, fail, then we seem to be forced
to postulate an elemental agency in nature manifesting itself in the
phenomena of the organism, but not in those of inorganic nature. This
argument _per ignorantium_ possesses little force to many minds: it
makes little appeal to the thinker, or the critic, or the general
reader, but it is almost impossible to over-estimate the appeal which
it makes to the investigator, as his experience of the phenomena of the
organism increases, and as he feels more and more the difficulty of
describing in terms of the concepts of physics the activities of the
living animal.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account