The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's AesthetikHegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich
Philosophy
The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich
Aesthetics
And the reason of this is that comedy too, viewed as genuine art, has
not the task set before it to display through its presentation what
is essentially rational as that which is intrinsically perverse and
comes to naught, but on the contrary as that which neither bestows
the victory, nor ultimately allows any standing ground to folly and
absurdity, that is to say the false contradictions and oppositions
which also form part of reality. The masculine art of Aristophanes,
for instance, does not turn into ridicule what is truly of ethical
significance in the social life of Athens, namely genuine philosophy,
true religious faith, but rather the spurious growth of the democracy,
in which the ancient faith and the former morality have disappeared,
such as the sophistry, the whining and querulousness of tragedy, the
inconstant gossip, the love of litigation and so forth; in other
words, it is those elements directly opposed to a genuine condition of
political life, religion and art, which he places before us in their
suicidal folly. Only in more modern times do we find in such a writer
as Kotzebue the baseness possible which throws over moral excellence,
and spares and strives to maintain that which only exists under a
condition of sufferance. To as little extent, however, ought the
individual's private life suffer substantial injury in comedy. Or to
put it otherwise, if it is merely the appearance and imagined presence
of what is substantive, or if it is the essentially perverse and petty
which is asserted, yet in the essential self stability of individual
character the more exalted principle remains, which in its freedom
reaches over and beyond the overthrow of all that such finite life
comprises, and continues itself in its character of self-security and
self-blessedness. This subjective life that we above all identify with
comic personality has thus become master of all the phenomenal presence
of the real. The mode of actual appearance adequate to what is, so to
speak, substantive, has vanished out of it; and, if what is essentially
without fundamental subsistence comes to naught with its mere pretence
of being that which it is not, the individual asserts himself as master
over such a dissolution, and remains at bottom unbroken and in good
heart to the end.[37]
(_γ_) Midway between tragedy and comedy we have furthermore a _third_
fundamental type of dramatic poetry, which is, however, of less
distinctive importance, despite the fact that in it the essential
difference between what is tragic and comic makes an effort to
construct a bridge of mediation, or at least to effect some coalescence
of both sides in a concrete whole without leaving either the one or the
other in opposed isolation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account