The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
for this short-sighted traffic of misguided human nature is
enlightenment,--"instruction publique et privee des lois de l'ordre
naturel."[6]
The nature in terms of which all knowledge of phenomena--for the present
purpose economic phenomena--is to be finally synthesised is, therefore,
substantially of a quasi-spiritual or animistic character. The laws of
nature are in the last resort teleological: they are of the nature of a
propensity. The substantial fact in all the sequences of nature is the
end to which the sequence naturally tends, not the brute fact of
mechanical compulsion or causally effective forces. Economic theory is
accordingly the theory (1) of how the efficient causes of the _ordre
naturel_ work in an orderly unfolding sequence, guided by the
underlying natural laws--the propensity immanent in nature to establish
the highest well-being of mankind, and (2) of the conditions imposed
upon human conduct by these natural laws in order to reach the ordained
goal of supreme human welfare. The conditions so imposed on human
conduct are as definitive as the laws and the order by force of which
they are imposed; and the theoretical conclusions reached, when these
laws and this order are known, are therefore expressions of absolute
economic truth. Such conclusions are an expression of reality, but not
necessarily of fact.
Now, the objective end of this propensity that determines the course of
nature is human well-being. But economic speculation has to do with the
workings of nature only so far as regards the _ordre physique_. And the
laws of nature in the _ordre physique_, working through mechanical
sequence, can only work out the physical well-being of man, not
necessarily the spiritual. This propensity to the physical well-being of
man is therefore the law of nature to which economic science must bring
its generalisations, and this law of physical beneficence is the
substantial ground of economic truth. Wanting this, all our speculations
are vain; but having its authentication they are definitive. The great,
typical function, to which all the other functioning of nature is
incidental if not subsidiary, is accordingly that of the alimentation,
nutrition of mankind. In so far, and only in so far as the physical
processes contribute to human sustenance and fullness of life, can they,
therefore, further the great work of nature. Whatever processes
contribute to human sustenance by adding to the material available for
human assimilation and nutrition, by increasing the substance disposable
for human comfort, therefore count towards the substantial end. All
other processes, however serviceable in other than this physiological
respect, lack the substance of economic reality. Accordingly, human
industry is productive, economically speaking, if it heightens the
effectiveness of the natural processes out of which the material of
human sustenance emerges; otherwise not. The test of productivity, of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account