The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
The discipline of social and civic life under a regime of status, then,
reenforces the discipline of the religious life; and the outcome of the
resulting habituation is that the canons of knowledge are cast in the
animistic mold and converge to a ground of absolute truth, and this
absolute truth is of a ceremonial nature. Its subject-matter is a
reality regardless of fact.
The outcome, for science, of the religious and social life of the
civilisation of status, in Occidental culture, was a structure of
quasi-spiritual appreciations and explanations, of which astrology,
alchemy, and mediaeval theology and metaphysics are competent, though
somewhat one-sided, exponents. Throughout the range of this early
learning the ground of correlation of phenomena is in part the supposed
relative potency of the facts correlated; but it is also in part a
scheme of status, in which facts are scheduled according to a
hierarchical gradation of worth or merit, having only a ceremonial
relation to the observed phenomena. Some elements (some metals, for
instance) are noble, others base; some planets, on grounds of ceremonial
efficacy, have a sinister influence, others a beneficent one; and it is
a matter of serious consequence whether they are in the ascendant, and
so on.
The body of learning through which the discipline of animism and
invidious comparison transmitted its effects to the science of economics
was what is known as natural theology, natural rights, moral philosophy,
and natural law. These several disciplines or bodies of knowledge had
wandered far from the naive animistic standpoint at the time when
economic science emerged, and much the same is true as regards the time
of the emergence of other modern sciences. But the discipline which
makes for an animistic formulation of knowledge continued to hold the
primacy in modern culture, although its dominion was never altogether
undivided or unmitigated. Occidental culture has long been largely an
industrial culture; and, as already pointed out, the discipline of
industry, and of life in an industrial community, does not favor the
animistic preconception. This is especially true as regards industry
which makes large use of mechanical contrivances. The difference in
these respects between Occidental industry and science, on the one hand,
and the industry and science of other cultural regions, on the other
hand, is worth noting in this connection. The result has been that the
sciences, as that word is understood in later usage, have come forward
gradually, and in a certain rough parallelism with the development of
industrial processes and industrial organisation. It is possible to hold
that both modern industry (of the mechanical sort) and modern science
center about the region of the North Sea. It is still more palpably true
that within this general area the sciences, in the recent past, show a
family likeness to the civil and social institutions of the communities
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account