The Poetical Works of William Collins; With a MemoirCollins, William
General
The Poetical Works of William Collins; With a Memoir
Collins, William
Poetry
It is evident that Homer has availed himself of those magnificent images
and descriptions so frequently to be met with in the books of the Old
Testament; and why may not Theocritus, Moschus, and Bion have found
their archetypes in other eastern writers, whose names have perished
with their works? yet, though it may not be illiberal to admit such a
supposition, it would certainly be invidious to conclude, what the
malignity of cavillers alone could suggest with regard to Homer, that
they destroyed the sources from which they borrowed, and, as it is
fabled of the young of the pelican, drained their supporters to death.
As the Septuagint translation of the Old Testament was performed at the
request, and under the patronage, of Ptolemy Philadelphus, it were not
to be wondered if Theocritus, who was entertained at that prince's
court, had borrowed some part of his pastoral imagery from the poetical
passages of those books. I think it can hardly be doubted that the
Sicilian poet had in his eye certain expressions of the prophet Isaiah,
when he wrote the following lines:
Νυν ια μεν φορεοιτε βατοι, φορεοιτε δ’ ακανθαι.
Ἁ δε καλα Ναρκισσος επ’ αρκευθοισι κομασαι;
Παντα δ’ εναλλα γενοιτο, και ἁ πιτυς οχνας ενεικαι
–––και τως κυνας ὡλαφος ἑλκοι.
~Nyn ia men phoreoite batoi, phoreoite d' akanthai.
Ha de kala Narkissos ep' arkeuthoisi komasai;
Panta d' enalla genoito, kai ha pitus ochnas eneikai
----kai tôs kynas hôlaphos helkoi.~
Let vexing brambles the blue violet bear,
On the rude thorn Narcissus dress his hair,
All, all reversed--The pine with pears be crown'd,
And the bold deer shall drag the trembling hound.
The cause, indeed, of these phenomena is very different in the Greek
from what it is in the Hebrew poet; the former employing them on the
death, the latter on the birth, of an important person: but the marks of
imitation are nevertheless obvious.
It might, however, be expected, that if Theocritus had borrowed at all
from the sacred writers, the celebrated pastoral epithalamium of
Solomon, so much within his own walk of poetry, would not certainly
have escaped his notice. His epithalamium on the marriage of Helena,
moreover, gave him an open field for imitation; therefore, if he has any
obligations to the royal bard, we may expect to find them there. The
very opening of the poem is in the spirit of the Hebrew song:
Ουτω δη πρωιζα κατεδραθες, ω φιλε γαμβρε;
~Houtô dê prôiza katedrathes, ô phile gambre;~
The colour of imitation is still stronger in the following passage:
Αως αντελλοισα καλον διεφαινε προσωπον,
Ποτνια νυξ ἁτε, λευκον εαρ χειμωνος ανεντος;
Hωδε και ἁ χρυσεα Ἑλενα διεφαινετ’ εν αμιν,
Πιειρα μεγαλα ἁτ’ ανεδραμε κοσμος αρουρα.
Hη καπω κυπαρισσος, η ἁρματι Θεσσαλος ἱππος.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account