Fiction -- History and criticism; Political fiction -- History and criticism; Politics in literature
In 1952 James T. Farrell published a novel which also dealt with
Communism in the mid-thirties. It was _Yet Other Waters_, the story of
Bernard Carr’s attraction to Marxism and his subsequent break with it.
This sometimes turgid book centers around the relation of the writer
to the Communist movement. Many of the phenomena of the period are
there: the magazines purveying a Marxist interpretation of literature,
the writers’ councils and congresses, the attempts to generate a party
literature. Never a member of the Party, Carr is torn between an
attraction to its stated aims and repulsion at its rigid control of
thought and art. He joins picket lines, reads a paper at a Congress,
and then sees the Communists turn a Socialist meeting into a riot.
When he breaks with his party friends, he is given “the treatment.” He
is vilified in the left wing papers and reviews as party hacks make a
concerted attempt to destroy his literary reputation. (And, of course,
this attempted destruction of his means of livelihood is the same
method used by the extreme Right to punish political divergency in _The
Troubled Air_ and _Stranger Come Home_.) Unfortunately, the charge that
Farrell has a tin ear in writing dialogue is true. This long book has a
considerable cumulative effect, but one pays for it by wading through
many slow-moving passages. On the whole, though, it is a convincing
portrait in depth, valuable also for its retroactive anticipation of
the so-called “Literature of Disillusionment” which was to come from
such writers as Silone and Koestler.
Like Hemingway’s _For Whom the Bell Tolls_, Dos Passos’ _Adventures
of a Young Man_ had in its later sections described the fight against
Fascism in the Spanish Civil War. Both novels recorded the infiltration
of the Loyalist forces by the Communists and the supremacy which they
achieved in many sectors. In his next book, _Number One_, Dos Passos
turned his attention to a source of growing concern to many Americans:
dictatorship on the state level as exemplified by the Long machine in
Louisiana. Two other novels, Adria Locke Langley’s _A Lion Is in the
Streets_ (1945) and Robert Penn Warren’s _All the King’s Men_ (1946),
are similar to it, although the quality of the writing varies greatly.
Dos Passos’s style is characteristically dispassionate and panoramic.
Warren’s book, despite devices smacking of melodrama, has sweep and
a highly evocative poetic prose. Langley’s novel is full of worn
devices: the faithful mammy with the corn-pone accent, the deathbed
message, hidden documents, and a shadowy avenger. But all three books
have their primary historical source in the career of Huey Long or the
forces in American political life which he typified.
=Upton Sinclair and John Dos Passos: Global War and Politics=
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account