The Principles of AestheticsParker, De Witt H. (De Witt Henry)
Philosophy
The Principles of Aesthetics
Parker, De Witt H. (De Witt Henry)
Aesthetics
Although the quantitative theory of modern verse has been pretty
generally abandoned, it cannot be said that the ordinary view which
regards the foot as the unit of verse and its rhythm as determined by
a regular distribution of accented and unaccented syllables, is in a
much better case. For in the first place, by accent is usually meant
word-accent; but monosyllabic words have no word-accent; hence, in
a succession of such syllables, the accent must be determined by some
other factor; and, granting this, there is the further fact to be
reckoned with, that poetic accent is relative--the supposedly unaccented
syllable is often very highly accented, more highly in fact than some
of the so-called accented ones. Consider, for example, the line, "From
sullen earth sings hymns at heaven's gate," where the word "sings,"
which in accordance with the conventional iambic scansion would be an
unaccented syllable, is really strongly accented, more strongly, indeed,
than "earth" which has an accent. As for the division of the line into
feet, that is a pure artifice: who, in the actual reading of the above
line, would divide the words "sullen" and "heaven" into two parts?
The basis of rhythm is, therefore, not word-accent. Value stress is
the basis.[Footnote: Throughout the discussion of rhythm I borrow from
Mark H. Liddell: _An Introduction to the Study of Poetry._] Certain
words, because of their logical or emotional importance, have a greater
claim upon the attention, and this inner stress finds outward expression
in an increased loudness, duration, and explosiveness of sound. Stress
coincides with the word-accent of polysyllabic words because the accent
is placed on those syllables, usually the root-syllables, which carry
the essential meaning. And this stress is not simply present or absent
in a syllable, but greater in some than in others; in iambic rhythm,
usually greater in the even than in the preceding odd syllable; in
trochaic, greater in the odd than in the immediately preceding even
one. The rhythm is rather an undulation of stresses than an alternation
of stress and lack of stress, something, therefore, far more complex
and variegated than the old scheme would imply. And of this undulation,
not the foot, but the line is the unit. The character of the undulation
of the whole line determines the type of the rhythm, which may be very
different in the case of lines of precisely the same kind of "feet."
For example, the line quoted above, "From sullen earth sings hymns at
heaven's gate," has a distinctly different rhythm from such another
iambic line as "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?" This difference
is due, in part at least, to the fact that the highest peaks of the
wave in the former are in the center of the line, in "sings" and
"hymns," while in the latter they are at the end, in "summer's" and
"day." This undulation of stress is present in prose and in ordinary
speech; for there also there is a rise and fall of stress corresponding
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account