The Principles of Psychology, Volume 1 (of 2)James, William
Philosophy
The Principles of Psychology, Volume 1 (of 2)
James, William
Psychology
"All the evidence that we have goes to show that the physical world
gets along entirely by itself, according to practically universal
rules.... The train of physical facts between the stimulus sent into
the eye, or to any one of our senses, and the exertion which follows
it, and the train of physical facts which goes on in the brain, even
when there is no stimulus and no exertion,--these are perfectly
complete physical trams, and every step is fully accounted for by
mechanical conditions.... The two things are on utterly different
platforms--the physical facts go along by themselves, and the mental
facts go along by themselves. There is a parallelism between them,
but there is no interference of one with the other. Again, if anybody
says that the will influences matter, the statement is not untrue, but
it is nonsense. Such an assertion belongs to the crude materialism of
the savage. The only thing which influences matter is the position
of surrounding matter or the motion of surrounding matter.... The
assertion that another man's volition, a feeling in his consciousness
that I cannot perceive, is part of the train of physical facts which
I may perceive,--this is neither true nor untrue, but nonsense; it
is a combination of words whose corresponding ideas will not go
together.... Sometimes one series is known better, and sometimes
the other; so that in telling a story we speak sometimes of mental
and sometimes of material facts. A feeling of chill made a man run;
strictly speaking, the nervous disturbance which coexisted with that
feeling of chill made him run, if we want to talk about material
facts; or the feeling of chill produced the form of sub-consciousness
which coexists with the motion of legs, if we want to talk about
mental facts.... When, therefore, we ask: 'What is the physical link
between the ingoing message from chilled skin and the outgoing message
which moves the leg? 'and the answer is, 'A man's will,' we have as
much right to be amused as if we had asked our friend with the picture
what pigment was used in painting the cannon in the foreground, and
received the answer, 'Wrought iron.' It will be found excellent
practice in the mental operations required by this doctrine to imagine
a train, the fore part of which is an engine and three carriages
linked with iron couplings, and the hind part three other carriages
linked with iron couplings; the bond between the two parts being made
up out of the sentiments of amity subsisting between the stoker and
the guard."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account