The Principles of Psychology, Volume 2 (of 2)James, William
Science
The Principles of Psychology, Volume 2 (of 2)
James, William
Psychology
"In the compartment of a railway-carriage six persons unknown to
each other sit in lively conversation. It becomes a matter of regret
that one of the company must alight at the next station. One of
the others says that he of all things prefers such a meeting with
entirely unknown persons, and that on such occasions he is accustomed
neither to ask who or what his companions may be nor to tell who or
what he is. Another thereupon says that he will undertake to decide
this question, if they each and all will answer him an entirely
disconnected question. They began. He drew five leaves from his
note-book, wrote a question on each, and gave one to each of his
companions with the request that he write the answer below. When the
leaves were returned to him, he turned, after reading them, without
hesitation to the others, and said to the first, 'You are a man of
science'; to the second, 'You are a soldier'; to the third, 'You are a
philologer'; to the fourth, 'You are a journalist'; to the fifth, 'You
are a farmer.' All admitted that he was right, whereupon he got out
and left the five behind. Each wished to know what question the others
had received; and behold, he had given the same question to each. It
ran thus:
"'What being destroys what it has itself brought forth?'
"To this the naturalist had answered, 'vital force'; the soldier,
'war'; the philologist, 'Kronos'; the publicist, 'revolution'; the
farmer, 'a boar'. This anecdote, methinks, if not true, is at least
splendidly well invented. Its narrator makes the journalist go on to
say: 'Therein consists the joke. Each one answers the first thing that
occurs to him,[115] and that is whatever is most newly related to his
pursuit in life. Every question is a hole-drilling experiment, and the
answer is an opening through which one sees into our interiors.'... So
do we all. We are all able to recognize the clergyman, the soldier,
the scholar, the business man, not only by the cut of their garments
and the attitude of their body, but by what they say and how they
express it. We guess the place in life of men by the interest which
they show and the way in which they show it, by the objects of which
they speak, by the point of view from which they regard things, judge
them, conceive them, in short by their mode of _apperceiving_....
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account