The Principles of Psychology, Volume 2 (of 2)James, William
Science
The Principles of Psychology, Volume 2 (of 2)
James, William
Psychology
Most persons, on being asked _in what sort of terms they imagine
words_, will say 'in terms of hearing.' It is not until their attention
is expressly drawn to the point that they find it difficult to say
whether auditory images or motor images connected with the organs of
articulation predominate. A good way of bringing the difficulty to
consciousness is that proposed by Stricker: Partly open your mouth and
then imagine any word with labials or dentals in it, such as 'bubble,
'toddle.' Is your image under these conditions distinct? To most
people the image is at first 'thick,' as the sound of the word would
be if they tried to pronounce it with the lips parted. Many can never
imagine the words clearly with the mouth open; others succeed after a
few preliminary trials. The experiment proves how dependent our verbal
imagination is on actual feelings in lips, tongue, throat, larynx, etc.
"When we recall the impression of a word or sentence, if we do not
speak it out, we feel the twitter of the organs just about to come
to that point. The articulating parts--the larynx, the tongue, the
lips--are all sensibly excited; a _suppressed articulation is in fact
the material of our recollection_, the intellectual manifestation, the
_idea_ of speech."[69]
The open mouth in Stricker's experiment not only prevents actual
articulation of the labials, but our feeling of its openness keeps
us from imagining their articulation, just as a sensation of glaring
light will keep us from strongly imagining darkness. In persons
whose auditory imagination is weak, the articulatory image seems to
constitute the whole material for verbal thought. Professor Stricker
says that in his own case no auditory image enters into the words of
which he thinks.[70] Like most psychologists, however, he makes of
his personal peculiarities a rule, and says that verbal thinking is
normally and universally an exclusively motor representation. _I_
certainly get auditory images, both of vowels and of consonants, in
addition to the articulatory images or feelings on which this author
lays such stress. And I find that numbers of my students, after
repeating his experiments, come to this conclusion. There is _at first_
a difficulty due to the open mouth. That, however, soon vanishes, as
does also the difficulty of thinking of one vowel whilst continuously
sounding another. What probably remains true, however, is that most men
have a less auditory and a more articulatory verbal imagination than
they are apt to be aware of. Professor Stricker himself has acoustic
images, and can imagine the sounds of musical instruments, and the
peculiar voice of a friend. A statistical inquiry on a large scale,
into the variations of acoustic, tactile, and motor imagination, would
probably bear less fruit than Galton's inquiry into visual images. A
few monographs by competent observers, like Stricker, about their own
peculiarities, would give much more valuable information about the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account