The principles of science : $b a treatise on logic and scientific methodJevons, William Stanley
Philosophy
The principles of science : $b a treatise on logic and scientific method
Jevons, William Stanley
Logic; Science -- Methodology
Probably the simplest of all forms of inference is that which has been
called *Immediate Inference*, because it can be performed upon a single
proposition. It consists in joining an adjective, or other qualifying
clause of the same nature, to both sides of an identity, and asserting
the equivalence of the terms thus produced. For instance, since
Conductors of electricity = Non-electrics,
it follows that
Liquid conductors of electricity = Liquid non-electrics.
If we suppose that
Plants = Bodies decomposing carbonic acid,
it follows that
Microscopic plants = Microscopic bodies decomposing
carbonic acid.
In general terms, from the identity
A = B
we can infer the identity
AC = BC.
This is but a case of plain substitution; for by the first Law of
Thought it must be admitted that
AC = AC,
and if, in the second side of this identity, we substitute for A its
equivalent B, we obtain
AC = BC.
In like manner from the partial identity
A = AB
we may obtain
AC = ABC
by an exactly similar act of substitution; and in every other case
the rule will be found capable of verification by the principle of
inference. The process when performed as here described will be quite
free from the liability to error which I have shown[55] to exist in
“Immediate Inference by added Determinants,” as described by Dr.
Thomson.[56]
[55] *Elementary Lessons in Logic*, p. 86.
[56] *Outline of the Laws of Thought*, § 87.
*Inference with Two Simple Identities.*
One of the most common forms of inference, and one to which I shall
especially direct attention, is practised with two simple identities.
From the two statements that “London is the capital of England” and
“London is the most populous city in the world,” we instantaneously
draw the conclusion that “The capital of England is the most populous
city in the world.” Similarly, from the identities
Hydrogen = Substance of least density,
Hydrogen = Substance of least atomic weight,
we infer
Substance of least density = Substance of least atomic weight.
The general form of the argument is exhibited in the symbols
B = A (1)
B = C (2)
hence A = C. (3)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account