The principles of science : $b a treatise on logic and scientific methodJevons, William Stanley
Philosophy
The principles of science : $b a treatise on logic and scientific method
Jevons, William Stanley
Logic; Science -- Methodology
Sodium is a metal (1)
Metals conduct electricity, (2)
we may conclude that
Sodium conducts electricity. (3)
Taking A, B, C to represent the three terms respectively, the premises
are of the forms
A = AB (1)
B = BC. (2)
Now for B in (1) we can substitute its expression as given in (2),
obtaining
A = ABC, (3)
or, in words, from
Sodium = sodium metal, (1)
Metal = metal conducting electricity, (2)
we infer
Sodium = sodium metal conducting electricity, (3)
which, in the elliptical language of common life, becomes
“Sodium conducts electricity.”
The above is a syllogism in the mood called Barbara[60] in the truly
barbarous language of ancient logicians; and the first figure of the
syllogism contained Barbara and three other moods which were esteemed
distinct forms of argument. But it is worthy of notice that, without
any real change in our form of inference, we readily include these
three other moods under Barbara. The negative mood Celarent will be
represented by the example
[60] An explanation of this and other technical terms of the old
logic will be found in my *Elementary Lessons in Logic*, Sixth
Edition, 1876; Macmillan.
Neptune is a planet, (1)
No planet has retrograde motion; (2)
Hence Neptune has not retrograde motion. (3)
If we put A for Neptune, B for planet, and C for “having retrograde
motion,” then by the corresponding negative term c, we denote “not
having retrograde motion.” The premises now fall into the forms
A = AB (1)
B = B*c*, (2)
and by substitution for B, exactly as before, we obtain
A = AB*c*. (3)
What is called in the old logic a particular conclusion may be deduced
without any real variation in the symbols. Particular quantity is
indicated, as before mentioned (p. 41), by joining to the term an
indefinite adjective of quantity, such as *some*, *a part of*,
*certain*, &c., meaning that an unknown part of the term enters into
the proposition as subject. Considerable doubt and ambiguity arise out
of the question whether the part may not in some cases be the whole,
and in the syllogism at least it must be understood in this sense.[61]
Now, if we take a letter to represent this indefinite part, we need
make no change in our formulæ to express the syllogisms Darii and
Ferio. Consider the example--
[61] *Elementary Lessons in Logic*, pp. 67, 79.
Some metals are of less density than water, (1)
All bodies of less density than water will float
upon the surface of water; hence (2)
Some metals will float upon the surface of
water. (3)
Let
A = some metals,
B = body of less density than water,
C = floating on the surface of water
then the propositions are evidently as before,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account