The Problems of Psychical Research: Experiments and Theories in the Realm of the SupernormalCarrington, Hereward
Science
The Problems of Psychical Research: Experiments and Theories in the Realm of the Supernormal
Carrington, Hereward
Parapsychology
"We cannot be permanently satisfied with dualism, but it is
possible to be over-hasty and also too precisely insistent. There
are those who seem to think that a monistic view of existence
precludes the legitimacy of speaking of soul and body, or of God
and spiritual things, or of guidance and management, at all; that
is to say, they seem to think that because these things can be
_ultimately_ unified, therefore they are unified proximately and
for practical purposes. We might as well urge that it is incorrect
to speak of the chemical elements, or of the various materials with
which, in daily life, we have to deal, or of the structures in
which we live, or which we see and handle, as separate and real
things, because in the last resort we believe that they may all be
reduced to a segregation of corpuscles, or to some other mode of
unity.... The language of dualism or of multiplism is not incorrect
or inappropriable or superseded because we catch ideal glimpses of
an ultimate unity; nor would it be any the less appropriable if the
underlying unity could be more clearly or completely grasped. The
material world may be an aspect of the spiritual world, or _vice
versa_ perhaps; or both may be aspects of something else; but both
are realities, just the same, and there need be no hesitation in
speaking of them clearly and distinctly as, for practical purposes,
separate entities."
This, it seems to me, disposes of the argument for Christian Science
drawn from idealism. No matter whether the material world exists or not,
we always have to live _as if_ it existed. If we close our eyes and walk
across the room, we shall be rudely stopped by the brick wall at the
opposite end when we come to it. No matter how strongly we believe that
such a wall does not exist, it does, nevertheless, stop us; we have to
live _as if_ it existed. And, just so, it seems to me; no matter how
strongly we may believe that the body does not exist, we always have to
live and act _as if_ it existed--so long, at least, as we live in and
inhabit the body at all.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account