The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
The declared composition of the preparation is unscientific, and the
therapeutic claims are unwarranted.
EUPEPTIC HYPOPHOSPHITES
Nelson, Baker & Co., Detroit, Mich., who market Eupeptic
Hypophosphites, call this preparation:
“A superior combination containing the Hypophosphites of Potassium,
Calcium, Iron and Manganese, and the bitter tonics, Quinin and
Strychnin, agreeably associated with natural digestive ferments
of the pancreatic secretion. It is thus a general reconstructive
tonic.... The remedy is of especial value in the treatment of
mental and nervous affections.... It is indicated in pulmonary
tuberculosis, in all wasting diseases, in debilitated conditions
generally and in all exhaustion from over work.”
On the basis of the manufacturer’s statement, Eupeptic Hypophosphites
must be regarded as a semisecret, unscientific, shotgun preparation,
exploited through unwarranted therapeutic claims.
MCARTHUR’S SYRUP OF THE HYPOPHOSPHITES COMP. (LIME AND SODA)
So far as the recent literature and trade package are concerned, no
information as to the composition of this product is furnished beyond
what is conveyed in the name. The advertising for McArthur’s Syrup,
like that for Fellows’ Syrup and Peters’ Syrupus Roborans, has been
modified as time has passed. A few years ago it was advertised under
such claims as the following:
“... Has Stood the Test during many years for unequaled efficacy
in the treatment of Tuberculosis.... Indicated also as a Tonic and
Tissue Builder in convalescence from Fevers, in Nervous Diseases,
Rickets, Senile Debility and Bronchitis.”
“Its use is indicated in ... diseases of the chest, chronic cough,
throat affections, general debility, brain exhaustion, cholera
infantum and wasting diseases of children.”
At present no definite claims seem to be made for it; the manufacturers
evidently find the magic name of hypophosphites sufficient to evoke
the spell for which the advertisement writer’s aid was once sought.
A testimonial contained in a circular which seems to be still used
illustrates both the kind of aura which surrounds hypophosphites in
the minds of physicians who are still living in the past, and the kind
of logic which has made the reputation of this and many other equally
worthless preparations.
“Just about six years ago I had a severe attack of La Grippe which
almost killed me. Left me with Asthma (Catarrh) and a severe cough.
Did not get out of the house for three months. Took over a dozen
bottles McArthur’s Hypophos.--came out all right and since then
worked hard, but last Fall took another cold, but worked on, used
McArthur’s Hypophos., am using it now, am on my 12th bottle.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account