The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
[Editorial Note..--With one exception, this product does not appear to
be advertised in medical journals. We find, however, in the gallery
of nostrums that grace the advertising pages of the _International
Journal of Surgery_, that Sulfuryl Monal has its place. According to an
advertisement that has been running some months in this publication,
“affections of the throat and respiratory organs respond promptly” to
Sulfuryl Monal whose “effects are rapid and certain” even in “incipient
tuberculosis.” This preposterous pronouncement is no worse than many
others appearing in the same journal, but it is bad enough to indicate
how uncritical must be the physicians who support--by subscription
or contribution--publications that are still debasing scientific
medicine.]--(_From The Journal A. M A., Sept. 16, 1916._)
MARK WHITE GOITER SERUM AND MARK WHITE IODINIZED OIL
Report of the Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry
The “Mark White Goiter Serum Laboratories” of Chicago asked the Council
to consider its products “Mark White Goiter Serum” and “Mark White
Iodinized Oil.” The “serum” was claimed to be an “antibody blood serum
from a goat with thyroidosis” while the “Iodinized Oil” was said to
contain “about 4 grains of iodin” to “each c.c.” The therapeutic
indications for the treatment were given as:
“Simple or Exophthalmic Goiter, Hyperthyroidism-dosis, Thyrosis,
Thyroidosis, Thyrotoxicosis, Dementia.”
An ampule (2 c.c.) of the “serum” is to be injected into the thyroid
to be followed one week later by an ampule (2 c.c.) of the “Iodinized
Oil.” Repetition of this “treatment” once or twice a month is advised.
The Council asked for more specific information as to the composition
of the remedies, particularly as to the preparation and nature of the
serum; it also asked for evidence of the therapeutic value of the
preparations. In reply, Mark White wrote:
“All that I can say regarding the serum is that it is made from the
blood of goats with thyroid affection, and it has been found that
the serum from these goats has antibodies which control, or has
curative effect upon thyroid affections when injected into thyroid
glands of either humans or animals. As to the iodinised oil, it
is only an adjunct or side treatment which is not always used or
indicated, and will only be furnished to the physician for use in
case in his judgment his patient needs it. We shall also advise the
use of quinin ... when indicated....”
The Council was referred for further information to a paper by Rachel
Watkins, M.D., published in the _Illinois Medical Journal_. It is to
be noted, incidentally, that the letterheads used by White in his
correspondence bore in one corner the notation “Rachel Watkins, M.D.,
Practice Limited to Goiter and Other Disorders of the Thyroid Glands,”
and in the other, “Mark White, Goiter Research.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account