The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
This statement throws no light on the discrepancies in the statements
with regard to the place of the iodinized oil in the treatment, namely:
(_a_) the original statement that the oil was to be given a week after
the serum; (_b_) White’s statement (quoted earlier in this report) that
the oil “is only an adjunct or side treatment” and “is not always used
or indicated”; (_c_) the statement in Dr. Watkins’ paper that the oil
and the serum are given in combination.
The Council declared the Mark White Goiter Serum and Mark White
Iodinized Oil ineligible for New and Nonofficial Remedies and
authorized publication of this report.
Editorial Note on the Mark White “Serum”
As some of our readers will remember, on April 26, 1913, The Journal
called attention to the Mark White preparation which at that time was
being exploited from Denver. The Propaganda Department has in its files
a number of letters sent out from the Mark White concern at various
times. One mailed in May, 1911, on the embossed stationery of “The Mark
White Goiter Institute,” Exchange Building, Denver, was evidently a
general letter sent to physicians, calling their attention to “the most
important medical discovery of the age.” “Dr. Mark White, a graduate
of the University of Pennsylvania,” said the letter, had discovered “a
simple and harmless remedy” that would cure goiter. “Because of the
desire to preserve the secrecy of this remedy it is given only at the
office here.” It was then suggested that the doctor might send those
of his patients who were suffering from thyroidism to the “Mark White
Goitre Institute.” If he would do so he would be “given a commission
of $10, in cases of the $50 fee with the additional $5 for each $50
increase.” It closed with some casuistic arguments, presumably for the
purpose of overcoming the physician’s scruples, summing up the matter
with the statement:
“No right thinking man will allow a narrow and self-seeking system
of ethics to stand between him and his duty to the sick and
suffering.”
About 1912 the name of the concern seems to have been changed, for we
have in our files a letter addressed to a layman on the stationery of
the “Mark White Goitre Treatment Company.” According to this letterhead
the product this concern had for sale was “Goitreine” discovered by
Mark White, “President and General Manager.” Mr. White’s letter to the
sufferer from goiter assured him that if he would take “Goitreine”
he might “be practically sure of an immediate and permanent cure.”
“Goitreine,” according to White, “has absolutely and permanently cured
90 per cent.” of all cases of goiter in which it has been used--“and
the other ten showed remarkable improvement.” It was efficacious for
all forms of goiter and “cannot possibly harm.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account