The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
Page 19. “Our glutens ... are all thoroughly standardized, so that in
their use the physician and the patient know just the amount of starch
eaten.” This standardization is largely mythical. For instance, “Pure
Gluten Biscuit” claims 0 to 5 per cent. “carbohydrates (starch),”
whereas I find 14.84 per cent. carbohydrates with 4.02 per cent.
starch. “40 per cent. Gluten Flour” claims 40 per cent. gluten and
40 to 45 per cent. carbohydrates, whereas I find 33.63 and 55.35
per cent., respectively. “Pure Gluten Meal” claims 0 to 5 per cent.
“carbohydrates (starch)” whereas I find 16.77 per cent. carbohydrates
and 6.77 per cent. starch. I have a record of six analyses each of “40
per cent. Gluten Flour” and “40 per cent. Gluten Biscuit,” which show
the hollowness of this claim of “standardization.” The flour showed
33.6, 35.0, 42.9, 36.8, 35.6, and 40.9 per cent. of protein, with from
40.8 to 55.4 per cent. of carbohydrates; the biscuits 32.7, 33.2, 39.5,
43.3, 33.9, and 41.2 per cent. of protein, with from 41.1 to 54.0 per
cent. of carbohydrates. In fact, my experience shows that the Kellogg
products are more poorly “standardized” than most of the diabetic foods
on the market.
Page 20. “May be made to carry a large amount of fat in the form of
butter, a most desirable thing in the treatment of diabetes,” while on
page 16 the company claims that in an experiment of Minkowski on a dog,
butter “passed through the body without change, none being absorbed”;
these are certainly contradictory statements. The explanation is that
on the one page the company is exploiting its biscuits, and on the
other its nut preparations.
Page 20. Again the incorrect claim is made for “40 per cent. Gluten
Flour” that “we believe this to be the only standardized gluten flour
made.”
Page 21. The claim is made that flesh foods are “objectionable on
account of the large amounts of ptomains and toxins which they
contain.” I was not aware that fresh meats contained any ptomains
whatever. On the same page the claim is again made that by the use of
the Kellogg nut foods “diabetics lose their thirst,” a claim which I
think is more than doubtful.
Page 22. “Nuts are a whole food, containing all the elements required
for the perfect nutrition of the body.” A marked characteristic of
nuts is that they are not “a whole food,” as with the exception of
a few varieties, such as the chestnut, they are extremely poor in
carbohydrates, which fact gives them their value in the diabetic diet.
Page 23. “With the exception of the potato, the beet and the carrot,
vegetables contain little sugar or starch.” Corn, beans and peas are
all vegetables which are relatively high in carbohydrates, and for this
reason are specifically excluded from the diabetic’s dietary.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive