The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
The statements in the pamphlet and circular published are typical of
the whole method of exploitation. For example, can such claims as these
be surpassed by the veriest quack?
“SCIENCE cannot improve the means employed in producing THE RUSSELL
EMULSION.”
“GENIUS has not devised better methods than are used in
manufacturing THE RUSSELL EMULSION.”
“MONEY cannot buy better products than are used in THE RUSSELL
EMULSION.”
“EXPERIENCE cannot suggest a more nutritious combination of fats
than we use in THE RUSSELL EMULSION.”
The emulsion is said to be made of equal parts of beef-fat, coconut,
peanut and cottonseed oils, held in suspension by albumin. The latter
we are told is applied to each globule of the emulsion by an “elaborate
technical process” devised by Dr. Russell. The mixture is everywhere
spoken of as a “physiological” emulsion, but the word is always in
quotation marks. Why it is called “physiological” is not clear, but the
term may be counted on to impress the unthinking or the unscientific.
Numerous false and exaggerated statements are made about this
“physiological” emulsion with reference to food value. For instance:
“The nutritional value of fats differ; the nutritional value of
these fats and their increased efficiency by combination over all
others have been determined by extensive clinical observation.”
And also:
“The Russell Emulsion is approximated in food value by no other
emulsion or food product in existence.”
“A ‘physiological’ emulsion is a predigested food. It is absorbed
with little assistance from the digestive juices, and with no waste
of energy. It is, therefore, the ideal food....”
These are sample statements found in the pamphlet and accompanying
circular. A dozen or more pathologic conditions are mentioned in which
this “ideal food” is specifically indicated; but we find, also, this
curious statement: “Patients can rarely take this dose [speaking of the
maximum dose of 2 ounces night and morning] for more than three or four
weeks without showing symptoms of over-feeding.” This unguarded remark
about an ingestion of 48 grams of fat daily prompts one to ask what is
wrong with the “ideal predigested food.”
Russell is wedded to the idea that “lime starvation” is the main factor
in tuberculosis, and insists on the importance of large amounts of fat
for the “lime starved.”
“Dr. Russell was the original interpreter of the Lime Starved State
and originated The Lime Starvation Treatment in Tuberculosis. He
also first pointed out and emphasized the therapeutic importance of
regarding the combination of lime phosphate and casein, as brought
down by the rennet enzyme, as a chemical union.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account