The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
Wingrave[21] suggests the use of Formamint for infants! He recommends
that a tablet be crushed and wrapped in “butter cloth.” The ends of the
cloth are to be tied with thread, the Formamint is to be moistened, and
the packet is to be held in the mouth of the baby several times each
day.
[21] Wingrave: Lancet, London =2=:1067, 1906.
Young[22] published the results of some experiments by himself and
Delépine on the human throat. They dissolved a tablet in the mouth and
made swab cultures with the following results:
Immediately after taking the tablet 0 colonies
10 minutes after taking the tablet 35 colonies
30 minutes after taking the tablet 150 colonies
[22] Young: Lancet, London =1=:975, 1908.
They found no staphylococci at any time. Other results of swabbing
various parts of the throat before and after the use of Formamint,
reported by these investigators, show enormous reductions in the count,
claimed to be due to the action of Formamint. The count was made on
agar at 37 C., but they fail to state the time elapsing between taking
the Formamint and making the swab. Young also reports favorable
clinical results in cases of scarlet fever, diphtheria, sore throat,
and the like. It must be noted, however, that they state that the mouth
and fauces must first be thoroughly cleansed by swabbing and douching
before Formamint is used.
THE “CHEMICAL COMPOUND” CLAIM
The claims made in the advertising literature of Formamint are very
extravagant. Many are highly improbable. These statements will be
discussed later.
The statement is made that Formamint is a new chemical compound:
“Formamint is Pentamethanallactose, 5 CHOH + C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁. It is an
original combination of Formaldehyde with Lactose, a definite
chemical compound. The Formaldehyde molecule is locked up in it
until solution in the saliva takes place, when the Formaldehyde is
liberated in its _nascent_ state and is therefore active without
being irritant.”
Furthermore the makers contend that this new chemical compound is
entirely harmless. For example, Daus,[5] in an article on “The
Disinfectant Action of Formic Aldehyde on Mucous Membranes,” declares:
“No indication of irritant or other injurious action made its
appearance even after large doses. The urine remained free from
albumin and sugar.”
Such statements as these are found in the advertising literature:
“Formamint tablets are absolutely harmless and innocuous, even to
little children.”
“When dissolved in the saliva, Formamint Tablets liberate slowly
Nascent Formaldehyde in a most active yet non-irritant form.”
They maintain that Formamint is not only absolutely harmless, but
actually beneficial to the tissues. It may be used “to tone up and
strengthen the tissues, prevent hoarseness, and allay irritation in
singers, public speakers,” etc.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account