The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
Buchu Leaves 3-1/2 grains
Uva Ursi 1-1/8 grains
Pareira Brava 1-1/8 grains
Hyoscyamus 1-1/2 grains
Hops 1-1/2 grains
Acetate Potash 7-1/2 grains
Spirits Nitre 5 grains
Alcohol 5 per cent. (by volume)”
The manufacturer, J. S. Tyree, Washington, D. C., offers this formula
to the medical profession with the following claim:
“Approximate composition made [sic] by quantitative and qualitative
analysis of the finished product.”
It is also claimed that
“An even greater advantage of Tyree’s Buchu and Hyoscyamus Compound
over other drugs, lies in the fact that every constituent of
the former is required to conform to a fixed standard of active
principle strength; hence the results derivable from it are
absolutely uniform.”
These pretentious claims of scientific accuracy look rather absurd to
chemists. Many of the substances present in buchu, hops, hyoscyamus,
uva ursi and pareira brava are also present in other drugs; hence it
would never occur to a pharmaceutical chemist to try to ascertain the
composition of such a mixture as Tyree’s Elixir by “quantitative and
qualitative analysis of the finished product,” much less to determine
the “active principle strength” of each ingredient, for no methods are
known by which this can be done.
It is claimed that, because of the care exercised in making Tyree’s
Elixir
“... the results derivable from it are absolutely uniform.”
A moment’s reflection, however, must compel any physician to attribute
this statement, on the most charitable construction, to sheer
ignorance. Of course, even a definite chemical principle, such as
quinin, does not exert uniform clinical action, for clinical conditions
vary, and accordingly the patient may or may not be cured. It is simply
preposterous to claim that the clinical results obtained from such
substances as hops, pareira brava, buchu and uva ursi are absolutely
uniform.
A peculiarly vicious claim is that the elixir renders the mucous
surfaces of the genito-urinary tract “hostile to the multiplication of
the gonococci.” Since infection with the gonococcus produces the direst
results, any claim which means in plain English that the remedy assists
in producing a cure or in preventing infection with that organism
cannot be condemned too strongly. Uva ursi, to be sure, has some slight
antiseptic action but it is devoid of any curative action in gonorrhea
and the minute amounts that are present in the Tyree elixir are of no
more protective value against gonorrheal infection than a grain of
hexamethylenamin would be.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account