The Psychology of ArithmeticThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
The Psychology of Arithmetic
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Arithmetic -- Study and teaching
should be formed before, not during, the training in short division.
They are admirable at that point as practice on the division tables; are
of practical service in the making-change problems of the small purchase
and the like; and simplify the otherwise intricate task of keeping one's
place, choosing the quotient figure, multiplying by it, subtracting and
holding in mind the new number to be divided, which is composed half of
the remainder and half of a figure in the written dividend. This change
of order is a good illustration of the nearly general rule that "_When
the practice or review required to perfect or hold certain bonds can, by
an inexpensive modification, be turned into a useful preparation for new
bonds, that modification should be made._"
The bonds involved in the four operations with United States money
should be formed in grades 3 and 4 along with or very soon after the
corresponding bonds with three-place and four-place integers. This
statement would have seemed preposterous to the pedagogues of fifty
years ago. "United States money," they would have said, "is an
application of decimals. How can it be learned until the essentials of
decimal fractions are known? How will the child understand when
multiplying $.75 by 3 that 3 times 5 cents is 1 dime and 5 cents, or
that 3 times 70 cents is 2 dollars and 1 dime? Why perplex the young
pupils with the difficulties of placing the decimal point? Why disturb
the learning of the four operations with integers by adding at each step
a second 'procedure with United States money'?"
The case illustrates very well the error of the older oversystematic
treatment of the order of topics and the still more important error of
confusing the logic of proof with the psychology of learning. To prove
that 3 × $.75 = $2.25 to the satisfaction of certain arithmeticians, you
may need to know the theory of decimal fractions; but to do such
multiplication all a child needs is to do just what he has been doing
with integers and then "Put a $ before the answer to show that it means
dollars and cents, and put a decimal point in the answer to show which
figures mean dollars and which figures mean cents." And this is general.
The ability to operate with integers plus the two habits of prefixing $
and separating dollars from cents in the result will enable him to
operate with United States money.
Consequently good practice came to use United States money not as a
consequence of decimal fractions, learned by their aid, but as an
introduction to decimal fractions which aids the pupil to learn them. So
it has gradually pushed work with United States money further and
further back, though somewhat timidly.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account