The Psychology of ArithmeticThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
The Psychology of Arithmetic
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Arithmetic -- Study and teaching
Arithmetic, although it makes little or no appeal to collecting,
muscular manipulation, sensory curiosity, or the potent original
interests in things and their mechanisms and people and their passions,
is fairly well liked by children. The censuses of pupils' likes and
dislikes that have been made are not models of scientific investigation,
and the resulting percentages should not be used uncritically. They are,
however, probably not on the average over-favorable to arithmetic in any
unfair way. Some of their results are summarized below. In general they
show arithmetic to be surpassed in interest clearly by only the manual
arts (shopwork and manual training for boys, cooking and sewing for
girls), drawing, certain forms of gymnastics, and history. It is about
on a level with reading and science. It clearly surpasses grammar,
language, spelling, geography, and religion.
Lobsien ['03], who asked one hundred children in each of the first five
grades (_Stufen_) of the elementary schools of Kiel, "Which part of the
school work (literally, 'which instruction period') do you like best?"
found arithmetic led only by drawing and gymnastics in the case of the
boys, and only by handwork in the case of the girls.
This is an exaggerated picture of the facts, since no count is made of
those who especially dislike arithmetic. Arithmetic is as unpopular with
some as it is popular with others. When full allowance is made for this,
arithmetic still has popularity above the average. Stern ['05] asked,
"Which subject do you like most?" and "Which subject do you like least?"
The balance was greatly in favor of gymnastics for boys (28--1),
handwork for girls (32--1-1/2), and drawing for both (16-1/2--6).
Writing (6-1/2--4), arithmetic (14-1/2--13), history (9--6-1/2),
reading (8-1/2--8), and singing (6--7-1/2) come next. Religion,
nature study, physiology, geography, geometry, chemistry, language,
and grammar are low.
McKnight ['07] found with boys and girls in grades 7 and 8 of certain
American cities that arithmetic was liked better than any of the school
subjects except gymnastics and manual training. The vote as compared
with history was:--
Arithmetic 327 liked greatly, 96 disliked greatly.
History 164 liked greatly, 113 disliked greatly.
In a later study Lobsien ['09] had 6248 pupils from 9 to 15 years old
representing all grades of the elementary school report, so far as they
could, the subject most disliked, the subject most liked, the subject
next most liked, and the subject next in order. No child was forced to
report all of these four judgments, or even any of them. Lobsien counts
the likes and the dislikes for each subject. Gymnastics, handwork, and
cooking are by far the most popular. History and drawing are next,
followed by arithmetic and reading. Below these are geography, writing,
singing, nature study, biblical history, catechism, and three minor
subjects.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account