The Psychology of ArithmeticThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
The Psychology of Arithmetic
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Arithmetic -- Study and teaching
The second general fact is that certain bonds are of service for only a
limited time and so need to be formed only to a limited and slight
degree of strength. The data of problems set to illustrate a principle
or improve some habit of computation are, of course, the clearest cases.
The pupil needs to remember that John bought 3 loaves of bread and that
they were 5-cent loaves and that he gave 25 cents to the baker only long
enough to use the data to decide what change John should receive. The
connections between the total described situation and the answer
obtained, supposing some considerable computation to intervene, is a
bond that we let expire almost as soon as it is born.
It is sometimes assumed that the bond between a certain group of
features which make a problem a 'Buy _a_ things at _b_ per thing, find
total cost' problem or a 'Buy _a_ things at _b_ per thing, what change
from _c_' problem or a 'What gain on buying for _a_ and selling for _b_'
problem or a 'How many things at _a_ each can I buy for _b_ cents'
problem--it is assumed that the bond between these essential defining
features and the operation or operations required for solution is as
temporary as the bonds with the name of the buyer or the price of the
thing. It is assumed that all problems are and should be solved by some
pure act of reasoning without help or hindrance from bonds with the
particular verbal structure and vocabulary of the problems. Whether or
not they _should_ be, they _are not_. Every time that a pupil solves a
'bought-sold' problem by subtraction he strengthens the tendency to
respond to any problem whatsoever that contains the words 'bought for'
and 'sold for' by subtraction; and he will by no means surely stop and
survey every such problem in all its elements to make sure that no
other feature makes inapplicable the tendency to subtract which the
'bought sold' evokes.
To prevent pupils from responding to the form of statement rather than
the essential facts, we should then not teach them to forget the form of
statement, but rather give them all the common forms of statement to
which the response in question is an appropriate response, and only
such. If a certain form of statement does in life always signify a
certain arithmetical procedure, the bond between it and that procedure
may properly be made very strong.
Another case of the formation of bonds to only a slight degree
of strength concerns the use of so-called 'crutches' such as
writing +, -, and × in copying problems like those below:--
Add Subtract Multiply
23 79 32
61 24 3
-- -- --
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account