The Queen's Daughters in IndiaBushnell, Katharine C. (Katharine Caroline)
History
The Queen's Daughters in India
Bushnell, Katharine C. (Katharine Caroline)
Prostitution -- India; Women -- India -- Conduct of life; Women -- India -- Social conditions
This new Act, called the Cantonments Act Amendment Act, was passed on
February 8, 1895. The point which was gained by the passage of this
new Act was one of great importance, namely, that there were moral and
social questions involved in the treatment of contagious diseases due
to vice which could not be overlooked in the medical management of such
disorders without serious consequences. It was, in the nature of the
case, impossible to place these diseases on the same footing as other
contagious disorders. The reasons for this position have been recently
expressed very concisely and forcibly by the British Committee, in the
following language:--
"1. It casts no stigma on the name or character of a person to assert
that he, or she, is affected with 'cholera, smallpox, diphtheria, or
typhoid fever,' and it can be ascertained whether such statement be
true without shock to the feelings of the most refined. The opposite
is the case with venereal disease, in regard to which a mis-statement
is a virtual libel, and a compulsory examination is an indecent
outrage. 2. As regards the former classes of disease, no conceivable
measures can have any moral bearing; whereas in the latter class
compulsory (and in some of its relations, even voluntary) submission
to examination or treatment has the gravest moral consequences both
to the individual and to the community. 3. The procedure under the
rules you propose is as follows: The medical officer is informed by a
soldier that a certain woman is diseased. Believing that, he orders
her for examination at the hospital. She may be perfectly honourable
or perfectly healthy. In either case if she refuses to attend she is
held to be diseased and is expelled from the Cantonment. We submit
that the whole of this procedure, though it may be in words the same
as in a case of cholera, is in fact utterly different in the means
by which information is secured, in the nature of the evidence as to
fact, and in the consequences to the woman who disputes the fact. The
operation of the rules, so far as venereal disease is concerned, is
not general.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account