The Quest of the Simple LifeDawson, W. J. (William James)
Philosophy
The Quest of the Simple Life
Dawson, W. J. (William James)
Country life
We had no trivialities to talk about; none of those odds and
ends of gossip that do duty for conversation in cities; and thus such
talk as we had concerned itself with real thoughts, and the thoughts of
wise men and great writers.
One of the principal occupations of my first winter was the education
of my boys. After the approved modern fashion I had intrusted this
task to others, upon the foolish assumption that what I paid heavily
for must needs be of some value. I discovered my delusion the moment I
came to look into the matter for myself. I found that they knew
nothing perfectly: certain things they had learned by rote, and could
recite with some exactitude, but of the reasons and principles that
underlie all real knowledge they knew nothing. I believe this to be
characteristic of almost all modern education, especially since
competitive examinations have set the pace. The brain is gorged with
crude masses of undigested fact, which it has no power to assimilate.
Fragments of knowledge are lodged in the mind, but the mind is not
taught to co-ordinate its knowledge, or, in other words, to think and
reason. The yearly examination papers of public schools and
universities afford ample and often amusing illustrations of this
condition of things. I remember an Oxford tutor, who set papers for a
certain Theological College, telling me that one year he put this
question: 'Give some account of the life of Mary, the mother of our
Lord.' This was a question which obviously required some power of
synthesis, some exercise of thought and skill in narrative. One bright
youth, after a feeble sentence or two in which the name of Mary was at
least included, went on to say, 'At this point it may not be out of
place to give a list of the kings of Israel.' Here was something he
did know, and it was something not worth knowing. I found that my boys
had been educated on much the same principle. They could do a simple
problem of mathematics after a fashion; that is, they could recite it;
but it had never once been suggested to them as an exercise of reason.
It was the same with history; they could recite dates and facts, but
they had no perception of principles. It may be imagined that I had to
go to school again myself before I could attempt to instruct them. I
had to take down again my long disused Virgil and Cicero, and work
through many a forgotten passage. At first the task was distasteful
enough, but it soon became fascinating. My love of the classics
revived. I began to read Homer and Thucydides, Tacitus and Lucretius,
for my own pleasure. It was delightful to observe what interest my
boys took in Virgil, as soon as they discovered that Virgil was not a
mere task-book, but poetry of the noblest order. By avoiding all idea
of mere unintelligent task-work, I soon got them to take a real
interest in their work, until at last they came to anticipate the hour
of these common studies. I took care also to never make the burden of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account