The right hand : $b Left-handednessWilson, Daniel, Sir
History
The right hand : $b Left-handedness
Wilson, Daniel, Sir
Left- and right-handedness
As already noted, Dr. Boyd gives as the result of his observations on
upwards of 500 human brains, that the weight of the left hemisphere
almost invariably proved to be in excess of that of the right. In forty
cases Dr. Broca found similar results, and observers of less note
confirm them; so that but for the eminent authorities by whom those
conclusions have been challenged, it would seem presumptuous to refuse
them acceptance. But, countenanced by this conflict of opinion, it may
be permissible to review the question in the narrower aspect of the
present inquiry. Testing it then by a reverse process, and assuming
hypothetically that the exceptionally dexterous right-handed man
will be found to have the left hemisphere the heavier, and the true
left-handed man _vice versâ_, the results arrived at by Dr. Boyd are
altogether in excess of what might be anticipated. The number of the
exceptionally dexterous right-handed, with an invincible instinctive
preference for the use of that hand, though large in comparison with
the no less dexterous left-handed, are nevertheless a minority. Habit,
social usage, and education in all its forms, in the school, the
drawing-room, the workshop, in all the arts of peace, and in nearly
every operation of war, have so persistently fostered the development
of the favourite hand that it is scarcely possible to arrive at any
reliable statistics in proof of the initial proclivities of the large
majority of conformists. Only a prolonged series of observations such
as those already noted by Professor Baldwin, made at the first stage
of life, and based on the voluntary and the unprompted actions of the
child, can supply the needful data. But the careful observations of
many years, prompted by a desire to master the source of an exceptional
instinctive habit, have convinced me that the bias towards the
preferential use of either hand in many, probably in the majority of
cases, is slight. It is sufficient to lead to their following the
practice of the determinately right-handed majority, but would not in
itself present an obstacle to conformity to any prevalent usage, or
to the influence of education. If then the preference of either hand
furnishes any index of the relative development of the two cerebral
hemispheres, what we may reasonably look for is a certain considerable
percentage of brains with the weight of the left hemisphere in
excess; a small percentage equally definitely characterised by the
preponderance in the right hemisphere; while in the average brain
the difference will be so slight as to be apt to escape observation.
It is further to be noted that if the habitual use of the right hand
tends in any degree to stimulate the development of the left cerebral
hemisphere, then the examples of strongly-marked cases of such must
greatly exceed those of the reverse type; since the left-handed man is
almost invariably ambidextrous, and so subjects both hemispheres to the
frequent stimulus of efferent nerve-force.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account