The right hand : $b Left-handednessWilson, Daniel, Sir
History
The right hand : $b Left-handedness
Wilson, Daniel, Sir
Left- and right-handedness
This idea of a greater development of the left cerebral hemisphere
has been the subject of considerable diversity of opinion. A marked
difference in the weight of the two hemispheres has indeed been
repeatedly asserted by well-qualified observers as the result of
careful investigation. M. Broca stated that in forty brains he found
the left frontal lobe heavier than the right; and Dr. Boyd, when
describing the results obtained by him from observations on upwards
of 500 brains of patients in the St. Marylebone Hospital, says: “It
is a singular fact, confirmed by the examination of nearly 200 cases
at St. Marylebone, in which the hemispheres were weighed separately,
that almost invariably the weight of the left exceeded that of the
right by at least the eighth of an ounce.” Dr. Brown-Sequard also,
as hereafter noted, makes this apparent excess in weight of the left
hemisphere of the brain the basis of very comprehensive deductions.
Again Dr. Bastian affirms, as a result of careful observation, that
the specific gravity of the gray matter from the fronted, parietal,
and occipital convolutions respectively is often slightly higher on
the left than it is on the right hemisphere. The opinion is thus
sustained by some of the most eminent physiologists who have given
special attention to the brain and its functions. But, on the other
hand, Professor Wagner and Dr. Thurnam both state that their careful
independent investigations failed to confirm the results arrived at
by M. Broca and Dr. Boyd. From the weighing of the two hemispheres of
eighteen distinct brains, Professor Wagner found the right hemisphere
the heavier in ten, and the left in six cases, while in the remaining
two they were of equal weight. Dr. Thurnam, without entering into
details, states that the results of his weighings did not confirm
Dr. Boyd’s observations; adding that “fresh careful observations are
certainly needed before we can admit the general preponderance of the
left hemisphere over the right.” Though the two hemispheres of the
brain are sufficiently distinct, they are united at the base; and even
with the most careful experimenters, the section through the cerebral
peduncles and the corpus callosum is so delicate an operation that a
very slight bias of the operator’s hand may affect the results. That
a difference, however, is occasionally demonstrable in the weight of
the two hemispheres is unquestionable, and the whole tendency of the
most recent investigation is to sustain the hypothesis which refers the
cause of left-handedness to an exceptional excess of nervous force in
the right cerebral hemisphere. But the results to be anticipated from
the partial character of the bias in the majority of the right-handed
would tend to suggest a doubt as to the full acceptance of the
statement of Dr. O’Connor adduced above. It is rather in accordance
with what has already been affirmed as to the very partial prevalence
of any strongly defined bias in the majority for the preferential
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account