International law; Natural law; War (International law)
History furnishes us with innumerable examples of deceptions practised
with success upon an enemy, by assuming his arms, ensigns, colours, or
uniforms; all which may be justified upon the same principle. For all
these are actions, which any one may avail himself of at his pleasure,
by departing from the usual course of his military system. For such
points of discipline and system depend upon the will and fancy of the
military commanders in each state, rather than upon any invariable
custom, equally binding upon all nations.
IX. Those signs, by which the daily intercourse of life is maintained,
form a subject of more weighty discussion, with which the consideration
of lies or falsehood is necessarily interwoven.
All stratagems of this kind are so direct a violation of all moral
principle, both in their nature and consequences, that almost every
page of the revealed will of God declares their condemnation. Solomon
describes a righteous, that is, a good man, as one, who holds every
false word in detestation, deprecating the least appearance of
deception: and the Apostle's injunction accords with these sentiments,
instructing his disciples not to lie to one another.
Nor is it in the high standard of perfection alone, which the divine
records present, that such a recommendation of fair, open, and sincere
dealing is to be found. It is the theme of praise with poets and
philosophers, and the angry hero of the Grecian poet declares, that
he detests the man, as an infernal being, who utters one thing with
his tongue, while he conceals another in his heart. But making some
allowance for poetic fiction--we find even the grave, sober, and
discerning, Stagirite describing falsehood, as a vile, and abominable
refuge, and painting truth as a lovely object, that must extort the
warmest praise.
These are all great and high authorities in favour of open dealing.
Yet there are names of no less weight, both among sacred and profane
writers, whose opinions are a vindication of stratagems, when used upon
PROPER occasions. One writer speaks of a case, where stratagem may be
used, even for the benefit of the person, on whom it is practised, and
adduces the instances of a physician, who, by means of a deception,
overcame the perverseness of a patient, and wrought a salutary cure.
X. To reconcile such a variety of discordant opinions, it may be
necessary to devise some way of examining falsehood both in its more
extensive, and more confined acceptation. Nor is speaking an untruth,
UNAWARES, to be considered in the nature of a lie, but the falsehood,
which comes within the limits here defined, is the KNOWN and DELIBERATE
UTTERANCE of any thing contrary to our real conviction, intention, and
understanding.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account