The Roman assemblies from their origin to the end of the RepublicBotsford, George Willis
History
The Roman assemblies from their origin to the end of the Republic
Botsford, George Willis
Constitutional law -- Rome; Rome -- Politics and government
II. (_a_) Concilium may apply to a non-political as well as to a
political gathering; (_b_) comitia is wholly restricted to the political
sphere.
(_a_) Concilium is non-political in Cicero, _Div._ i. 24. 49 (deorum
concilium); _Tusc._ iv. 32. 69; _N. D._ i. 8. 18; _Off._ iii. 5. 25; 9.
38: _Senec._ 23. 84; _Fin._ ii. 4. 12 (virtutum concilium); _Rep._ i. 17.
28 (doctissimorum hominum in concilio); _Sest._ 14. 32 (applied to the
meeting of a collegium); Livy i. 21. 3 (Camenarum concilia); ii. 38. 4;
xxvii. 35. 4.[742]
III. Within the political sphere, again, (_a_) concilium is the more
general term,—it suggests neither organization nor lack of organization;
whereas (_b_) comitia is restricted to the organized assembly.
(_a_) Concilium is the more general term in Cicero, _Fin._ iii. 19. 63;
ii. 24. 77; _Rep._ vi. 13 (3). 13.[743] In all these citations concilia,
denoting assemblies of the whole people, must certainly include organized
meetings, without excluding the unorganized. In _Leg._ iii. 19. 42
(“Invito eo qui cum populo ageret, seditionem non posse fieri, quippe
cui liceat concilium, simul atque intercessum turbarique coeptum sit,
dimittere”) concilium is probably the organized assembly. On the other
hand, the concilium of all the people mentioned by Livy, i. 8. 1, may
have been unorganized.
IV. Within the province of organized national gatherings, on the other
hand, (_a_) comitia is the wider term, applying as it does to all
assemblies of the kind, whatever their function; whereas (_b_) concilium
as an organized national assembly is wholly restricted to legislative and
judicial functions.[744]
(_a_) Comitia is used in its most general sense in Cicero, _Div._ i. 45.
103; ii. 18. 42 f.; 35. 74; _Tusc._ iv. 1. 1.[745]
V. (_a_) Applied to foreign institutions, comitia always designates
electoral assemblies; (_b_) as at Rome, concilia are always legislative
or judicial assemblies.[746]
(_a_) Comitia is used of foreign states in:
Caesar, _B. G._ vii. 67; Cicero, _Verr._ II. ii. 52. 128 (three
occurrences), 129, 130; 53. 133; 54. 136; _Fam._ viii. 1. 2;
Livy v. 1. 1; xxiv. 23. 1; 26. 16; 27. 1; xxxii. 25. 2; xxxiii.
27. 8; xxxiv. 51. 5.
(_b_) Foreign concilia are mentioned by:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account