The Roman Poets of the Republic, 3rd editionSellar, W. Y. (William Young)
History
The Roman Poets of the Republic, 3rd edition
Sellar, W. Y. (William Young)
Latin poetry -- History and criticism
The history of the physical science of the ancients cannot, indeed, be
regarded as so interesting or important as that of their metaphysical
philosophy. And this is so, not only on account of the comparative
scantiness of their real acquisitions in the one as compared with the
ideas and method which they have contributed to the other, and with
the masterpieces which they have added to its literature; but still
more on this account, that in physical knowledge new discovery
supplants the place of previous error or ignorance, and can be
understood without reference to what has been supplanted; whereas the
power and meaning of philosophical ideas is unintelligible, apart from
the knowledge of their origin and development. The history of physical
science in ancient times affords satisfaction to a natural curiosity,
but is not an indispensable branch of scientific study. The history of
ancient mental philosophy, on the other hand,--the source not only
of most of our metaphysical ideas and terms, but of many of the
most familiar thoughts and words in daily use,--is the basis of all
speculative study. Yet among the various kinds of interest which this
poem has for different classes of modern readers this is not to be
forgotten, that it enables a student of science to estimate the
actual discoveries, and, still more, the prognostications of discovery
attained by the irregular methods of early enquiry. The school of
philosophy to which Lucretius belonged was distinguished above other
schools for the attention which it gave to the facts of Nature.
Though he himself makes no claim to original discovery, he yet shows
a philosophical grasp of the whole system which he adopted, and
a rigorous study of its details. He does not, like Virgil, merely
reproduce some general results of ancient physics, to enhance the
poetical conception of Nature: as he is not satisfied with those
general results about human life and the origin of man, which amused
a meditative poet and practical epicurean like Horace. He was a real
student both of the plan of Nature and of man's relation to it. Out
of the stores of his abundant information the modern reader may best
learn not only the errors but also the happy guesses and pregnant
suggestions of ancient science.
To the general reader there is another aspect, in which it is
interesting to compare these germs of physical knowledge with some
tendencies of scientific enquiry in modern times. The questions,
vitally affecting the position of man in the world, which are
discussed or raised by Lucretius in the course of his argument, are
parallel to certain questions which have risen into prominence in
connexion with the increasing study of Nature. Most conspicuous
among these is the relation of physical enquiry to religious belief.
Expressions such as this,
Impia te rationis inire elementa viamque
Indugredi sceleris,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account